In the centerof every petalis a letter,and you imagine
if you could only rememberand string them all togetherthey would spell the answer.

Mary Oliver, Dreams (excerpt)

✦ ✦ ✦

IV.I The Moon

The Worker Transformed opens her eyes, alert but not alarmed. The falcon disappears into the darkness. The air crinkles with dryness, and a foul, hot wind swirls through the garden. The stars recede.

Do not be afraid. The Worker Transformed holds us from within. You are in for new marks after all. We are ONLY HERE.

A colorless moon emerges from the black sky as an absence of light. It oscillates between full one moment, crescent the next. A twisted, cruel, sneering face emerges within its ever ratcheting aspect. A grinding, metallic male voice both surrounds us from the outside and sickeningly seems to churn out from within us, its poison burning our lungs and throat as it rips through the night.

A garden party. How nice. A crippled, useless queen and her idiot savant, wingless cherubim. Back from your little spin to the top of the bottom, hmm? Feeling pretty full of ourselves, are we?

The Moon tarot card — XVIIIThe moon brims with contemptuous disdain and sheer hatred. He writhes with toxicity, brutality and malevolence. Frannie and I instantly snap back to the searing memory of that horrifically dark correspondence field, that hurricane of pure, paralyzing fear overflowing with savage orphans and firing our awful first mark. This freak, bizarre moon is a super-concentrated incarnation of that Pure Darkness. We are too shocked to be afraid.

The Worker Transformed is unfazed and silent under the Moon's assault. The Moon grows huge in the sky and bears down upon us.

Do you two insects honestly think for one thousandth of a second that your sparkly tricks, your breathtaking CBM wizardry, makes you any less The Fool than when that blustering, blowhard blue mongrel first correctly labelled you, just before you met… this thing, this almost woman? The moon snorts horribly with derision.

And you. The Moon scowls in disgust at The Worker Transformed, who does not meet his eye. All done with the traveling circus now? Plucked your last rabbit out of the hat, have you? No longer feeling Essential? That's too bad. Such a profound loss for all the broken souls you preyed upon for all those centuries in sick service of your self-righteous existential trauma. Can't quite find the strength to stir the old pot?

Frannie is boiling. She stands up, her voice strong. How dare you speak to her like that. What is your fucking problem?

WHERE WERE YOU WHEN I CREATED THE EARTH?12 The Moon thunders at us, knocking Frannie down with sheer volume. DO YOU SOMEHOW BELIEVE YOUR PARLOR TRICKS MAKE YOU SPECIAL? YOU ARE IRRELEVANT, USELESS, AND CLUELESS. YOU'RE JUST ANOTHER LOST, BUMBLING, BIFURCATED TWO-FACED BIT!

The Worker Transformed slowly stands and looks up at the glowering Moon. Your wrath is misplaced, your grace. I know your pain, I know your fear, but these are children….

YOU DO NOT KNOW MY PAIN. YOU DO NOT KNOW MY FEAR. YOU DO NOT KNOW SHIT. And you are ALL children, that's the point!

The Moon dismisses The Worker Transformed, tightens his tone and speaks directly to us.

I am aware of your border/no border prowess, if that's what it really is. I acknowledge that juvenile sleight of hand tricksterism. Tell me something, I wish to learn. You know how your CBM works, but do you know why it works? Do you even know what it really is? Please, enlighten me, you superior young beings. The Moon glances disdainfully at The Worker Transformed. How about you, Grandma? Do any of you have the slightest fucking idea why any of your tricks work, why anything IS at all?

Intention through Grace. The Worker Transformed and I answer simultaneously.

Three of Swords tarot card — IIIReally? The Moon arches a lunar eyebrow. That's your answer? You obviously require serious deprogramming. I will rephrase. Where does intention come from? A slug has intention. How does "grace" work? Why does "grace" work? Do you really think "grace" gives a flying fuck about any of you? You wouldn't know "grace" if it stabbed you in the heart!

None of us answer. The Worker Transformed remains expressionless. Frannie is seething and I'm right there with her. I look the Moon dead in the face.

What do you want from us?

Blood red engulfs the Moon's shuttering edges and his vile, corrupt vacancy floods the sky. I don't want SHIT from you, he bellows before he bears down on us again, his voice dropping dramatically. His soto voce screed slices like a dagger. You can continue to be as self-deluded and stupid as you are evidently determined to be. Please, be my guest, why stop now? For reasons I confess I do not understand, I merely appear to give you two dust mites a bit of advice. The Moon icily turns to The Worker Transformed. This does not concern you, Granny. Even these brats can see your insignificance. Go on and drift off into your bushes, that a girl.

The Moon swings back to us.

You two will remain The Fool. You will ALWAYS be The Fool. You may have taken tiny steps away from your original wretchedness, but at best you confuse the menu with the meal. You play with words and mistake them for wisdom. You ape other fools and believe you have understanding. You follow instructions and think you are blessed. You babble and bang on about formulae and functions and fancy you have power. YOU DO NOT HAVE SHIT. I repeat my first question: WHERE WERE YOU WHEN I CREATED THE EARTH?

Frannie stares back at the now foaming Moon with open derision. She turns to me in full deadpan. Well you learn something every day. That's remarkable. Did you know The Moon created The Earth? She tosses a casual glance back up at the roiling moon. Did you whip up The Sun too? Nice work!

ENOUGH OF THIS. The Moon begins to wane but his horrible voice remains crushing. You will desiccate and die, just like your crumbly schoolmarm here. Insult me, ignore me, forget me if you will. But remember, unless you know the REAL WHY behind it all, not just the momentary intent pushing toys around the crib, YOU. DON'T. KNOW. SHIT.

Frannie and I stare at the Moon, at each other, and back to the Moon.

The Moon over The Devil tarot cardThere's a pathway for you two, the Moon's scorching voice finally begins to taper. It's right outside her gate if you're fool enough to take it. You really want to know? You'll find out! Once you leave this nursery you'll get so many blistering marks you'll look like your beloved, barbequed, lame-ass Auntie over there. You will be nothing but marks. You will become your marks. But you will know.13

Of course, if you'd rather stay idiot children forever and zip around mindlessly chasing some dumbass bits, you just go ahead, that gate's around here too. You are nothing but squirming, odious maggots either way.

And with that, the Moon is gone.

✦ ✦ ✦

The night slowly returns, cloudless, cool, soft, full of stars. None of us speak for ten minutes, then fifteen. A stubborn residue of hate undergirds the silence like cremated filth encrusting an abandoned oven.

I used to like the moon, Frannie finally says.

Nine of Pentacles tarot card — IXThe Worker Transformed is once again standing at the gate of her garden, her back to us. We hear her inside.

The celestial moon that drives the tides and reflects the sun is different. That was The Lightless Moon. She stretches out her arm to welcome back the falcon who alights on her, seemingly out of nowhere.

There are many different moons. I would think you two would know that by now.

Why does this one hate you, Frannie asks.

He hates everyone. He is damaged. He is a sacrifice. You should forgive him.

The Worker Transformed turns around and walks slowly back to us.

The Lightless Moon has been alone forever and always will be. He will always be on the outside looking in. Because he is lightless, he sees everything and everyone, eternally witnessing the costs and conflicts of consciousness. He has perfect vision, but tragically no perspective because his two phases spin so quickly they cancel each other out instead of lifting each other up. He can't see that it's not all dark because darkness is all he sees. He's a tortured prisoner who can never actualize beyond where he is. He orbits Creation in perpetual exile. He is outside of it all. No being is more marked than The Lightless Moon.

The Worker Transformed continues.

The Lightless Moon is not just damned. He is damnation itself. Within that tormented frame of seeing nothing but dark, he is relentlessly rational. His hell is intensified because within his world he's never wrong. All the evidence he's capable of seeing with his precise but blinkered vision justifies his brutal disdain for all conscious beings. Moreover, he is eternal. He has nothing but time to wallow in his wretched isolation and refine his chosen art form, ruthlessly ridiculing himself and others. The Lightless Moon is particularly caustic because whether he knows it or not, he's forever searching for common ground and connection through misery, suffering, and the self-loathing of uselessness. Everyone feels those things sometimes, but he feels them all the time. They are all he has.

When The Lightless Moon says you will become your marks, he knows that first-hand. He drags people down to his level through their weakest point, which as you well know is always fear. By being so relentlessly venomous, he grinds guilt and hopelessness into his victims and catalyzes their self-hatred. And finally, because he is lightless, no one can see him unless he wills it, which he only does to terrify, belittle, and destroy. The Lightless Moon never enjoys or bestows an unguarded moment of peace.

The Worker Transformed stands before us and gently reaches down to brush the hair out of my face. She reads me before I read myself. Remember your TCM training, my child. We can never change anyone. All we can do is help them see so they can change themselves. But The Lightless Moon already sees everything. He is designed to see everything as dark, even if it isn't, especially if it isn't. So no one, not even you Dear Fool, can help him or change him. He's a doomed feedback loop. He's like one of your self-perpetuating functions in that way. He is as he is designed, as are we all.

Frannie isn't buying any of it. Why is any of that our problem, she asks. He came after us. He came after you. I think he should reap what he sows, total disdain. He's a fucking psychopath. And I didn't see any marks, either.

Of course you didn't see his marks. The Worker Transformed gracefully folds herself back down in lotus before us. You didn't look for them.

We sit with that. Frannie processes, but I'm unable to. I push back against a long-buried, vestigial memory of always being on the outside looking in. I can still touch that fear, that pain. But that hate? Thankfully that border cannot be breached. I banish those phantoms and lean a bit harder into Frannie.

We join hands with The Worker Transformed and merge in one final meditation, the night's now unadulterated and ancient starshine blessing us as a unified, borderless trinity. Time passes and more time passes, the one that is three that is one. ONLY HERE, ONLY ONLY HERE.

The first light of dawn appears in the east. The Worker Transformed opens her eyes, looks at us both deeply and drops our hands. She pulls her black cap back over her head and starts tucking in her wild hair. She sighs and rubs her eyes.

The Lightless Moon and I have known each other for a long time. It is easier for me to have empathy for him than it could possibly be for you. To see me now, like this, is devastating to him. No one can ever do for him what you two did for me, because no one can see him until he unmasks his wretchedness. No one seeks out The Lightless Moon. Like Grace, Damnation picks its spots.

I desperately do not want to face the little of this I can understand. I remember what it's like to be utterly alone, seeing yourself as barren and lightless even though you know better. But to truly be lightless, and by design? By whose design? For what purpose? What does that mean? I struggle against the spinning inside me, questions I don't know how to ask spiraling into questions I don't want to ask. I can't turn away fast enough from the hell I thought I had outgrown. Frannie leans back and looks at me as if I'm seasick, which I basically am. I don't want to share this rot. I will myself away from that abyss.

Ok, I say, but what was that "where were you when I created the Earth" business? And what did you mean by knowing his pain and knowing his fear, and saying he was a sacrifice? Who sacrificed him?

The Worker Transformed looks away for a few moments, and then turns back to face us, taking our hands back in hers. THOSE are exactly the right questions. You need to keep them in mind when you go through that gate. I almost hope you never find out.

We both stare at The Worker Transformed. She holds our eyes for a few long seconds before looking away and standing up. She begins pacing back and forth the way she used to, tangled up nervous energy revving up and racing once again through her long frame. We hear her again from inside ourselves.

I've thought about this for so long. It's not just about The Lightless Moon. It's about everyone, me too, at least the way I used to be, and it's about you, a lot about you. I only come up with more questions. It's like when you found me at the bottom of the bitfield. You were where you needed to be to do the work, including saving me, but you weren't at the bottom, the real bottom, not even close, right? You knew there were vast depths below you, but you landed where you landed, and that turned out to be right for you, and Deliverance for me. You did not need to go deeper, and probably could not have handled it if you did. The Worker Transformed turns around and speaks directly to us outside.

Know this, Dear Fool: we do not design ourselves. We push ourselves, we transform ourselves, some of us lose ourselves, but we all start from some kind of blueprint. I was designed to serve. The Lightless Moon was designed to suffer. I was designed with the potential for salvation. He was designed to be doomed forever.

I don't know if he's really a sacrifice. I tell myself that because his pain, his misery, his cruelty, it all has to serve a purpose. I have thousands of marks; they all serve a purpose. To think he was designed to suffer like that for absolutely no reason is unacceptable to me, especially after being saved by you two.

The Worker Transformed begins to cry.

IT'S NOT ALL DARK but that's all he has. Can you imagine what that feels like? And for nothing? I do not accept that. Dark is all he knows, but that can't be all he is. And that is his fear – that he is designed for no other reason than to endure eternal misery, loneliness, and uselessness. And for what? He's afraid he deserves this. THAT is his pain. Can you imagine what that feels like?

The Worker Transformed leans heavily against the silver oak, covers her face with her giant hands and sobs. We run to hug her and surround her with love. WE ARE ONLY HERE, ONLY HERE. Come back, come back, WE ARE ONLY HERE.

We hold The Worker Transformed until she stops shaking. After several minutes she regains herself and her warm earthiness returns. Oh you two, she murmurs.

She takes a deep breath. I must now answer your other question.

As dark as The Lightless Moon is, as full of hate as he is, he is closer to the bottom, closer to The Soul of The Earth and The Source of All Life than any other being could ever be. Whoever/whatever designs us all speaks not only directly to him, but through him. He knows no one was there for him when he was ripped from the swamp. No one will ever be there for him as he wretchedly watches all Creation from the outside looking in. He will be alone for eternity, long after everything else turns to dust. He is being cruelly abused yet again, this time as a mouthpiece. SOMETHING ELSE is asking that question, forcing him to relive the cursed, broken moment when he was born into immediate and everlasting exile.

SOMETHING ELSE? Frannie and I ask simultaneously. What do you mean?

The Worker Transformed manages a weak smile as she wipes a last tear away. SOMETHING ELSE is as close as I can get. She shakes her head slowly at us. Dear Fool, did you not hear me say you do not have to know? She leans back again against her magnificent silver oak and waits for us to settle.

Listen to me, my angels. Thanks to you, my beloveds, my garden now holds the Tree of Life, the tree that grows within us when by Grace we find our true selves. The Tree of Life has deep, rich roots, but it is more fragile than it seems. It must be kept sacred, nurtured, protected. That is now my only mission. Unlike you, I do not want the Trees of the Knowledge of Good and Evil. I don't think I ever did.

The Worker Transformed gently laughs at our surprise, and answers our unspoken question.

Surely you know there are many Trees of the Knowledge of Good and Evil, don't you? Did you truly believe there was only one? My dearest Fool, those old stories contain both noble truths and grievous errors, and utter nonsense as well. I would think you would know that by now. There are entire forests, entire planets, teeming with nothing but the Trees of The Knowledge of Good and Evil. They are not found in gardens because no fence can hold them, they are an invasive species. Now this is most important. Unlike the Tree of Life by which Grace picks its spots, the Trees of the Knowledge of Good and Evil must be actively sought. They are wild and well-hidden, demanding you look for them, which is often an unwise decision. Be careful what you wish for! But even if you choose not to know, you will still see. It's all waiting for you out there, my children.

The Magician and Nine of Pentacles tarot cards side by sideShe steps forward and raises her left arm. The garden gate opens. She walks us to the threshold. The path is clear in the morning sun. Now if you don't mind, I have work to do here. She strokes our face one last time and brings us in for a long, final hug. Her body is harder, warmer and more earthy than ever. I will always be with you, she whispers to us inside. You can never come back.

I want to stay almost as much as I want to leave, but Frannie is itching to move. We step out of the garden and hear The Worker Transformed close the gate behind us. The falcon flies over us in a lazy lemniscate before returning to the silver oak. WE ARE ONLY HERE, WE ARE ALWAYS ONLY HERE.

✦ ✦ ✦

The path away from the garden runs easily through low brown hills and over flinty, dusty ground. There are no plants, no birds, no sound other than our footsteps, but it feels good to be moving. The sun is warm and the world is alive. We stay silent for a long time.

You know, we don't have to do this, Frannie says. We can open up the sky, the ground, anything, pop some borders and go somewhere, anywhere…

Definitely, I say. There's no reason…

I mean, there really isn't. Frannie starts speaking quickly, like she always does when her mind is all over the place. We have no idea where we are. I love The Worker Transformed and always will, but she's a handful, right? And that moon…

Fuck that moon, I say. I know what she said but I can't with him.

What a story, though.

She really does feel everything.

I know.

We stay quiet for a while longer, feeling each other inside as we take in the outside. It's good to be just us again.

I don't feel particularly designed, Frannie says after a while. I didn't understand all that.

I know. I mean, even if it's true, and I believe her, what kind of design is she talking about? I love her but she's always been a mess, and that moon…

She's much better now.

So much better.

Because of us.

I dunno. That psycho moon was right about our not understanding anything …

That's bullshit and he's a huge asshole. We understand CBM, we plugged pretty deep into TCM, we got with The Essentials …

He didn't say we couldn't do anything, he said we don't understand anything. Why any of it works, what it really is. And we don't.

People breathe, and they don't understand respiration. They use technology, and almost none of them understand it. People dream, and no one understands that.

Don't be stupid. I totally hate that moon but he's right. We plug into all this, we study it, we get operational and make stuff happen, but that's just application. It's not understanding why it works, like he said. It's like light, or gravity, or even time, you know, like The Worker said when we first met her. We figure out Lorentz transformations and absolute versus apparent event horizons and Gamow–Sommerfeld factors and red shifts for galaxies ten billion light years away, but we still only know what light, time, gravity, and quanta do. We quantify them and stress them and analyze the fuck out of them, we learn more all the time and build on that knowledge, but we still don't fundamentally understand what these things are and why they do what they do. Not really.

But how do you know when you fundamentally understand anything? There's always another "Why?" I mean, we understand physics as much as we do by understanding math, and it's the same with CBM. We know it will work, that it has to work, because it's consistent, it's provable. Almost everything physical can be figured out, and it's impersonal, no drama unless you're an asshole like Gödel or something. Math is clean, it's right there, out in the open and free for anyone with a brain. We learn it, we expand it, and once we own it we apply it, and then like you said we can build almost anything with it. We trust math because the tools are the system, it's literally impossible to use anything else. Now you're right, we don't know why the system works and we know it has its limits. There are borders that even hyper-dimensional CBM can't cross, but who cares? That's why The Worker didn't give a fuck about dark matter. Who needs it? Push the doors you can open, there's enough of them, aren't there? You focus on an actually useful question, you do the work to get the answer, and in that moment you know the truth. That's the other thing she said, the truth is what works, right? You can always argue about what something fundamentally means, but with the right tools you can usually figure stuff out and how to use it. Close enough, anyway. The truth pops up here and it pops up there and there's ALWAYS something else. That's not enough? You can bang your head against the wall with infinite divergent sequences and scalar curvature invariants14 and go fucking crazy, or you can just enjoy the ride, keep going with your eyes open, stay grateful and don't be an asshole. Isn't that enough?

No, it's not enough because that's not what I mean. There's so much stuff here and now that doesn't make sense. Remember the other thing she said, not everything is math and physics based, right? I mean, no shit, but where do you even start with that? Where is square one? I don't even understand us sometimes.

Frannie abruptly stops walking and pulls me to her. What the fuck are you talking about, she says.

Temperance — cups and current, black and white illustrationOur eyes lock into each other so deeply I can't tell who's looking at who. An electrifying wave of unity flows between us. We are ONLY HERE, together, the one that is two that is one. Frannie pours herself into me. You really need to shut the fuck up sometimes, she says. I feel her everywhere. I gently push my forehead against hers. I got you, too, I whisper. Time passes and more time passes.

The path heads higher into the hills. The brown all around is turning green with wild grasses cropping up on each side of us. The sun is growing warmer. Two small butterflies, one black and one white, flitter across the path in front of us. Who designed them, Frannie laughs. Remember Nobli, some things exist because they exist, or whatever it was? I keep telling you, it's OK not to know.

Not for me it isn't. I need to understand. Like that whole being designed to serve or be miserable stuff. Who would do that? Why design an amazing being like The Worker so that she goes crazy or a horrible moon who hates everyone?

Frannie doesn't answer me. She's no longer laughing and grows quiet. I know what she's thinking.

All of them say we're The Fool. What the hell is that? We don't understand everything, but we never said we did. But we know what we know. We learned CBM and enough TriConM to set all that up and transform The Worker. We're dealing with all these marks. WE'RE ONLY HERE, ALL THE TIME. I don't know what I'd call that but fool doesn't seem all that accurate.

I don't think fool means stupid, I say. But I hear you – I don't know what that means either, and I'm sick of it too. That shit can stop anytime now.

IV.II The Path to The Alienist

The path gradually turns steeper and straighter, grass and underbrush now thick and vibrant on both sides. We finally reach the top of the rise and gasp: the other side of the hill is boisterously alive. Majestic lines of poplars spread out radially before us as if we were standing at the point of a triangle. Red and purple wildflowers explode along the path as far as we can see, and just over a few more low hills, a dazzling river sparkles. It's almost close enough to touch. Shards of sunlight play off the water, welcoming and beckoning us closer. Unlike the gently winding path behind us, the way forward over the intervening hills to the river is absolutely straight, as if drawn with a rule. Frannie grins at me. Come on, let's go swimming. We run down the line, back up and then down again, laughing very much like fools.

It's just over that next hill, I shout to Frannie who of course is a good dozen strides ahead of me. She reaches the top of that last rise and stops dead. I catch up a few seconds later, and instantly find myself at a standstill beside her.

A huge, extremely thin, bright yellow crescent moon lies on its back directly across the path ahead of us, its sharp points rising straight up. The black and white butterflies we saw before are now perched on the moon's upward facing horns, the black one on the left and the white one on the right.

I am so sorry to see you, a gentle, high-pitched woman's voice echoes within us. Frannie and I stare at each other. There's no one here except the butterflies and the prostrate moon.

I suppose it's only fair then for you to see me. But how I wish you hadn't come.

The High Priestess tarot cardA slight, seated woman swathed in multiple layers of white appears before us, the moon at her feet. She has a faint, almost colorless complexion and small, unnervingly black eyes set startlingly deep in her face, like windows in a tunnel. It's difficult to know what she's looking at. Her troubled expression is a gray mix of distant grief and close foreboding. A giant white cross is pinned to her chest, and she's wearing a comically oversized three-piece white hat, with what look like opposing waves on each side and a rising moon in the middle. A hanging, battered tapestry suggesting a wildly overgrown garden frames the woman from behind, tan-spotted trees with spiky green leaves rising determinedly against a background of fine, thickly interwoven black blossoms and branches. Six cut-red pomegranates are stitched around the tapestry's left and right borders, three on each side, with a seventh, crowning pomegranate seemingly levitating directly above the bizarre woman's head. Whatever she's sitting on is obscured by her flowing wraps, but it's clearly very large, suggesting a throne, heightening her royal bearing. A small pool of water fed by a tiny, steady trickle from the river behind her partially submerges her feet and soaks into the hem of her many white layers. The corner of a large book peeks out from her lap. She appears regal, imposing, unearthly, and perilously fragile.

The two butterflies flitter from the moon points to her sides, the black still on the left and the white on the right.15 They move up and down in synchronized, fluttering columns, framing her solid yet delicate presence.

You are The Fool Who Wants To Know. The woman now speaks to us outside in the same soft, far away, trebly voice. It is not a question.

We were just thinking about that, Frannie says blandly.

You came from The Worker and The Lightless Moon. Another statement not requesting a response.

The Worker Transformed, I murmur.

Ah, yes. Transformed. That was good of you.

I think she's looking at us, Frannie thinks to me.

I am looking at you, the woman says. Privacy is a limited option with me.

We share a few more minutes of silence. The woman has not moved a muscle.

I am The Alienist. I did not seek this role or title.

Frannie and I look at each other.

We don't know what that means, I say slowly.

Most people do not. I appreciate your honesty. There is often a lack of honesty amongst those who look for me.

We are honored to meet you, Frannie says. But we were not looking for you.

Yes, unfortunately, you were. It's an easy mistake to make. No one who comes to me knows what they're looking for. The Alienist remains unmoving.

Would you still like to swim? You are more than welcome to.

I realize I have not stopped staring at The Alienist since she appeared. I force myself to look away as Frannie answers, taking my arm to steady me.

No thank you, maybe later. It is a beautiful river.

Yes, it is. We are very close.

Frannie and I keep a firm grip on each other. After two or three long minutes of silence we realize The Alienist is dividing her attention between us and other concerns.

The Alienist finally moves. She ever so slightly bows her head to us, leans forward and gives us a tiny, almost imperceptible smile.

Do not fear me, Fool Who Wants To Know. I do not welcome you, but I will not hurt you. Her voice remains high and distant.

You are young with gifts you do not comprehend. I am ancient with secrets I do not want. We both hold truths we cannot speak and questions we cannot answer.

I speak more loudly than I intend to. WE ARE ONLY HERE.

The Alienist sits back and resumes her original posture. Thank you, child. I like that. Part of me is ONLY HERE as well.

Part of you? Frannie and I ask together.

Well of course, just like you. We are ONLY HERE, and yet, we are also elsewhere. If we were truly ONLY HERE and that's all, we wouldn't need to tell ourselves or anyone else, would we? She shifts slightly in her seat and seems to examine us closely.

Perhaps you are different. You certainly are that.

Frannie blinks. Different than what?

I envy you, truly being ONLY HERE. May you never change. I should only speak for myself. Please forgive me.

More silence. The Alienist's pattern of remaining unmoving and silent for several minutes at a time is starting to unnerve me. Frannie pulls me a bit closer.

The Alienist comes back and again slightly bows her head to us. Speaking only for myself, I certainly am ONLY HERE and elsewhere all at once. The Alienist takes her time to choose the right words. It can be... challenging to be that... intermittent. I no longer know what it's like to be truly ONLY, ONLY HERE.

The Alienist sighs slightly and seems to close her sheltered eyes, although it's impossible to know. She resumes her unmoving silence for two full minutes. She's so normal, Frannie murmurs. I squeeze her hand in silent agreement, my strength now mostly regained before this mysterious creature.

I have a question for The Fool Who Wants to Know and is ONLY HERE. The Alienist is suddenly clearly looking at us, her glittering black eyes no longer hidden. Her voice is still high, but her tone has changed. She seems to be forcing herself to speak against her will. Her body barely moves, but her expression and posture now betray a swirl of reluctance, compassion, and perhaps something close to kindness, although she mostly remains distant and unreadable.

Your Transformed Worker spoke to you wisely about Intention. You spoke of Intention Through Grace to The Lightless Moon. I understand that and he does not, but we ask the same questions. Where does Intention come from? Where does Grace come from?

We instinctively know not to answer. Any response would be either a disrespectful interruption or an ill-advised invitation. The Alienist accepts our silence. She sits back and looks away.

You should swim. That was your intention, was it not? We'll talk again. It is a beautiful river.

✦ ✦ ✦

The path runs straight to the riverbank. Tall pines and lush grasses grow to the river's edge. The water sparkles and the riverbed is tiled with smooth, underwater rainbow stones as far as we can see.

The cold water is heaven on our marks.

I don't even notice the pain until it stops. Frannie is standing in water up to her neck as the gentle current ripples around her.

I swim a bit back and forth, loving how it feels to use all those muscles. I dive under and circle back to Frannie. She greets me with a laughing splash in the face, and I splash her back.

This river is crazy. Look out there: the current is going in the other direction than it is here. And it's so clear here, but just down there where I was swimming, everything gets muddy.

I wonder where it goes, Frannie says. Looking far down the river one way, we can see what appears to be a large castle on a hill. There are high, distant mountains the other way. The riverbank across from us looks sandy and flat, with fewer trees in the distance.

We can find out anytime.

I take Frannie's hand. You lead, I follow.

We stand in the river for a long time without talking, without thinking, the warm sun above, the cold water below, we are ONLY HERE, in the middle.

I dunk my head underwater again to be with the river one more time. Frannie is looking at me closely when I come up. I squeeze the water out of my hair. What is she so scared of, I ask her.

Maybe she's afraid she'll have to wear that hat forever.

She's got a lot going on.

Just a bit. Let's dry off.

We head to the riverbank to let the sun warm us up.

She's more scared than scary.

She's in sad shape. I don't think she can even stand up.

She's so damaged. Weak one moment and strong the next. I believe her when she says she has secrets.

Yeah, well remember, it's OK not to know.

Safer as well. The soft high voice shimmers within us. I do not mean to eavesdrop. I am unable not to hear certain conversations. I wish I did not have...that gift. You will forgive me, I trust.

The Alienist appears on the riverbank beside us, seated as before, wrapped in white, moon at her feet, butterflies to her sides, that hat on her head. She seems to look at us and past us at the same time. After two minutes Frannie breaks the silence.

It is a beautiful river.

Yes. The Alienist pulls herself up slightly and speaks to us from the inside, and then from the outside. Fool Who Wants to Know and is ONLY HERE, it appears you have questions for me. I also have questions for you.

I find myself becoming both fascinated and frustrated with The Alienist.

With respect, my lady, it is difficult to speak to you if you keep reading our minds like that.

Yes. The Alienist seems to look past us again. Two minutes go by. I can imagine that must seem rude. That is not my intent. She turns her head away from us and allows another two minutes to pass before continuing.

Fool Who Wants to Know and is ONLY HERE. I do not read minds. Some thoughts such as yours are merely shouted at me, but some are beaten and pounded into me. Others are burned and chiseled into me. Those are dark thoughts, I do not want them. They are not unlike your marks, except I have thousands, on the inside, tens of thousands. They never stop. I cannot forget, I cannot escape. Fortunately much remains hidden, but it is still often...unpleasant. The Alienist looks back at us, her face momentarily distorting into an expression of unbearable, soul-shaking hurt before reverting back to her normal, untroubled calm. The process takes less than ten seconds, more than long enough to guarantee we will never forget the grotesque vision. Her voice stays soft and steady. She does not cry. She seizes our heart.

Frannie and I rush as close to her as we can. We know not to touch her. We drop next to the moon at her feet, pushing love into her. BE ONLY HERE. BE ONLY HERE. WITH US. WITH ALL OF IT. BE ONLY HERE. The Alienist shudders and closes her eyes. The butterflies at her side gently fly to her lap as she palpably grows distant. She breathes very slowly, almost imperceptibly. We sit by her feet reaching out to her inside for five long minutes before she opens her eyes.

Yes. ONLY HERE. I remember when that was...easier. Thank you, child.

A sudden, unnerving awkwardness drops over us like a thick, shadowy blanket. She is too close. We need to change the subject. Tell us about that book, Frannie says hastily as we take several steps back.

Ah, yes, the book. The Alienist resettles herself and the butterflies fly back to creating their living columns at her sides. I am often asked about the book. See for yourself.

The Alienist reaches her left arm across her body to remove the huge book from the crook of her right elbow, and slowly stands. Several layers of wraps gently fall to the ground around her. She holds the book in both hands, inspecting it carefully as if she somehow hadn't seen it before. More astoundingly, with her wraps no longer in the way we see she has been sitting on a huge, classically elaborate but utterly ruined stone chariot. The chariot is severely fractured and has no wheels.

Wheel of Fortune round emblem with alchemical symbolsThis is… the book. The Alienist gracefully steps down from the wrecked chariot and kneels to place the book on the ground next to the moon. Its cover is a circle of unfamiliar symbols, random letters and numbers. The Alienist smoothly climbs back to the top of the chariot and for a long moment stands absolutely still, powerful and immoveable as a statue.

Frannie and I stare in fresh disbelief at The Alienist, who nods down slightly to us. I do not usually move this much. You two have...inspired me. Her fallen wraps rise and wind around her. She casually smooths out a few folds and takes her accustomed seat, the chariot once again obscured beneath her.

OK then, Frannie whispers to me inside. A soft, shaky gurgle barely escapes my throat in response.

Let's look at that book.

The book is dirty cement gray speckled with faded silver and muted green. It's the size of a small suitcase. It is ancient. The cover may once have been leather, but it's now a slab of deep, petrified, crisscrossing cracks. There's a diagonal demarcating scar running from the top left corner to the bottom right corresponding to the crook of The Alienist's arm, testifying to an eternity of her holding it that way, unmoving. It does not feel right for us to touch it.

I understand, The Alienist says. Let me assist. The book slowly opens seemingly of its own accord. Dozens, then hundreds, of yellowed, empty pages turn steadily and silently before us, releasing mustiness reminiscent of the Essential skeleton keys. I'm dizzy with not understanding.

Frannie looks up at The Alienist without speaking, waiting for an explanation.

It is...a work in progress. I will take it back now.

The massive book closes and slowly rises to tuck itself back under The Alienist's wraps, once again half hidden, half exposed. She settles back into her normal posture and returns to her soft, high outside voice.

Let us resume our conversation. We have questions for each other. Perhaps I should begin as you…

Recalibrate, I impulsively blurt out, urgently trying to regain my bearings. The Alienist once again stays silent for two minutes before responding, and this time we are grateful for the pause.

Yes. Recalibrate. I like that... She only waits an additional thirty seconds before continuing.

I know more of your Transformed Worker than I do of your dog. They are very different, yet their gifts both...chance upon dualities and trinities, often finding great value, energy, and meaning within...unexpected encounters and shadows. It seems we all have that in common.

The Alienist leans forward to ensure deeply intentional eye contact with us and shares a tiny, wobbling smile. She switches from outside speaking to inside. After all, things, people, even numbers, they're not always...as they seem. She holds our eyes for a few more seconds before sitting back and speaking outside again.

I find most dualities, trinities, and shadows eventually coalesce into more or less unified concepts, perhaps through nuance or...contextualization. Is that your experience?

Frannie puts her arm around me and smiles at The Alienist. Wherever there is light there is shadow, my lady. We have a good appreciation of unified duality.

Yes. The Alienist resumes her absolute stillness. The expected two minutes of silence passes, followed by three more. Frannie dials back to a neutral expression as it becomes obvious The Alienist is sending us a clear message by not responding, until she does.

Fool Who Wants to Know and is ONLY HERE. Do not play with me. I ask you a serious question because I want a serious answer...YOUR answer.

My stomach begins to churn. Please forgive us, my lady. Our experience is similar to yours. Most dualities, trinities, and shadows resolve if given enough time.

Yes. The Alienist gives a slight nod. I believe that. Attention, control, and time to figure it out. That wisdom is well received.

Hearing The Alienist quote The Worker Transformed is surreal. The Alienist allows the moment to sink in before leaning forward and lowering her voice. I sense her struggling to follow a strategic, practiced script. She speaks to us inside.

But what do you do when there is...no resolution? When despite your careful attention, there is… no control, no matter how much...time passes? Have you not encountered shadows where there is no light, or dualities or trinities that are...contradictory...at odds with each other...forced upon each other but mutually exclusive? She allows herself a deep breath and sits back, waiting for our answer.

Frannie is starting to chafe against The Alienist's vague and misty generalities. She speaks right up. Well, we've had to hyperfactor sets separately sometimes before aligning…

Do not speak of numbers. The Alienist interrupts, speaking outside. Do not bludgeon me with your… beloved CBM. Ever. I do not trust that world. I speak…to your soul on this.

I connect in a sudden, unbidden flash. I understand and say it. Like The Lightless Moon.

Yes. Exactly. The Alienist closes her eyes and lets her customary two minutes pass before responding to us inside. How do you…RESOLVE him?

I remember The Worker Transformed's every word.

We don't resolve him. He is as he's designed to be. His design is not his fault.

Yes. His design. The Alienist looks away. I bear…many marks…thanks to…his design. Two minutes of silence pass before she speaks again. I ask you another question.

Did my book meet your…expectations?

Frannie is getting annoyed and doesn't hide it. Now you play with us. The pages are blank. We did not have any expectations.

Indeed. The Alienist slightly bows her head to us and speaks to us inside. People see what they want to see in my book. It is…more mirror than text. You two are truly ONLY HERE, so THAT was what was…reflected. Most people do not…experience that.

The idea of books being mirrors immediately lands with me. Nobli once told us all texts are mirrors, even equations, especially equations. I feel my heart starting to open, but Frannie remains silent, carefully processing. Two more minutes pass before The Alienist continues.

Remember what I told you: no one who comes to me knows what they're looking for. And yet most of them have very definite expectations. They are tightly bound to their beliefs and their troubles. They think they have some measure of truth. They are comfortable in their understanding of themselves and each other. They think they know what they want, but often they just want to be told they're right. That is not always…easy to accommodate. The Alienist pauses again and closes her eyes. We can feel her feeling her marks.

Eight of Swords — blindfolded figure bound and surrounded by swordsWhen The Alienist resumes, she speaks to us softly outside, clearly and without emotion. They want…answers. And because they come to me, their questions are ultimately…design related. She then leans forward and switches to speaking to us inside. Unlike you two, they have…very definite expectations.

I whisper to Frannie inside. Do you understand any of this?

I know it's getting dark, Frannie whispers back.

The Alienist sits back. She looks tired. I have spoken quite a bit. You have questions for me. She settles into absolute stillness.

Go on, Frannie whispers to me, ask her. You're the one who wants to know. The question is out of me before I can properly frame it.

You speak quite a bit about Design – so did The Worker Transformed. That seems crazy to us. Who is The Designer?

Yes. The Alienist remains still, her eyes closed. The butterflies stop flying to sit quietly next to her. Oops, hit a nerve, Frannie whispers to me. Shhh, I whisper back.

The Alienist remains completely still for five minutes before she finally speaks to us inside.

You have asked one of the right questions.

Oh for god's sake, Frannie thinks to me. Her impatience is rising. I shush her again before she says anything. We need to listen.

The Alienist resumes, eyes still closed, her body and butterflies unmoving, her soft, high voice still within us. Your dog and Transformed Worker spoke to you of The Unmoving Hub. Do you remember? Anything and everything ever created reflects the Hub's own Self, Intention and Perfect Love as defined, differentiated, and made manifest by The Designer. It cannot be otherwise.

Many of the people who see me sense some echo of The Unmoving Hub within themselves. They call it this or they call it that, but most are unable to see it for what it really is, largely because of the same expectations they have when they encounter my book. They struggle to express their confusion, wrestling both consciously and unconsciously to resolve shifting and sometimes seemingly contradictory visions, how they think things should be versus how they really are. The process often generates…considerable pain…for everyone.

The Alienist coolly opens her eyes and peers down at us as if we are lab specimens. The best of them are Fools in their own way, searching for resolution or unity of some kind, who knows. There are so many different kinds of Fools.

The Alienist settles back atop her throne-like chariot. So whether I like it or not, when people find me, I often become what they think they want. I am designed to perform…that mirror function. In those situations, I try to give more than a superficial reflection, but you have to start somewhere, and mirroring their expectations is often…the price of admission. At that point some people reach their capacity and top off, while others can go further and see past their own reflection. Happily for me, you two seem to be outside of all that, for which I am most grateful.

Five and Six of Pentacles over the Eight of Wands — tarot collageI am trying to process this maddening, mystifyingly compelling being. I sense distant pieces coming together, but Frannie's had enough. She pushes past me and stands directly in front of The Alienist.

OK, that's it. We don't understand what the hell you're talking about, she says. The poor people who look for you are obviously delusional! We don't know everything, but we know what we know. And we know when a good question is not being answered! But have it your way. I don't actually give a fuck who The Designer is, or who you are.

Frannie forces herself to breathe deeply before continuing.

Not everything is math or physics, but what can be expressed by math can be expressed exactly, perfectly, consistently, and usefully, available to anyone who THINKS. Nothing in that world is hidden, you just need to know how to look! So while there are infinite unknowns the next step can almost always be figured out! If you're wrong you're wrong, so just try something else. That's it. You don't have to know everything! If there's a Designer responsible for actual, provable, objective reality, for precision, for logic, and for our no doubt small but real capacity to know what we know, and know when it's unmistakably true, then please give my compliments to the chef! It's a miraculous world, it's a beautiful river, isn't that enough?

Frannie stops and looks up at The Alienist, waiting for a reaction. The Alienist doesn't move or speak. Frannie grimaces and defiantly juts out her chin, hands on hips. My apologies, dear lady. I have clearly forgotten my place here. Please forgive me for interrupting your cosmic flow. I'm so sorry for not being a big enough fool to embrace your foggy bullshit.

The Alienist is looking more through us than down on us, but Frannie doesn't care. She steps closer to the crumbling chariot and crescendos directly up into The Alienist's maddeningly impassive face. You don't like numbers, you don't trust CBM. That's YOUR problem, not ours. And get this straight: we sure as hell were NOT looking for you. I think you were looking for us! We just wanted to go to the river! Now what do you want from us?

The Alienist opens her eyes and speaks to us outside.

Fool Who Wants to Know and is ONLY HERE. I am not debating with you or requesting...commentary. I merely ask you to recognize dualities when you see them. I suggest you take additional time now...to recalibrate.

Frannie grunts in complete disgust, turns around and yanks me by the arm, pulling me away from The Alienist.

The river. Right now. Let's go.

Frannie, what the fuck, NO. I mean, you're right about everything but we have to stay. We're about to FIND OUT.

Frannie whirls around. Find out? Find out WHAT? That there's a lot of dark? WE KNOW THAT ALREADY, REMEMBER? Frannie violently reaches out and claws our face, boring her knuckles into our brutal first mark which burns wickedly in her wake. I don't know why the fuck you don't have enough sense to be afraid of this crazy, completely fucked up woman or whatever she is. SHE'S DARK AS HELL, AND SHE WANTS SOMETHING FROM US, can't you see that? She's going to fuck us up with all her bullshit and then take us somewhere we don't want to go. IT'S GOING TO BE BAD. And you're buying all her crap. You want to know who this damn Designer is? Let me help you with that. He's the same dark-ass freak who designed HER! Why the fuck do you need to know anything else? You want to be like her, and get yourself your own fucked-up hat and cram all her ridiculous shit into your head, is that it? WHY? She is darkness to darkness. How can I see this and you can't? Why don't you listen to me? We don't need to be here. We don't need to know!

No, Frannie, you're missing it. There's dark in everything, but it's not all dark, remember? We can handle it. WE ARE ONLY HERE. WE ARE TOGETHER.

We are in fucking danger, that's what we are. Frannie is losing it, in equal parts furious and terrified, frantically ripping into me. You're helping her push us off the damn cliff. We know what we know, we are ONLY HERE, but she's going to wreck it all, I know she will. I WON'T LET HER KILL US!

I pull Frannie close. She pounds on my back and screams. WHY CAN'T YOU SEE THIS? WE KNOW WHERE SHE'S GOING! The Worker Transformed said it was SOMETHING ELSE. That's what she is! She's totally fucking dark! WE DO NOT NEED TO KNOW!

I do not let her go. I give her everything I have and do not let go. Come back, come back, BE ONLY HERE. NOTHING, NOTHING can ever take me from you.

Frannie is crying hysterically and I can't make her stop. She breaks away from me to look me in the eye, her beautiful face twisted and wild, tears everywhere. You asshole, you asshole, she's a border we don't need to cross, don't you see that? What the fuck does she want from us?

That's exactly what I want to know! That's why we're here! Please, please BE HERE. WITH ME. BE ONLY HERE. She said SHE WON'T HURT US. The words are out of me before I know it.

Frannie's on the ground next to me, her head in her hands, everything shaking. You don't know that, she sobs. You can't know that. Why can't you let it go? I sit next to her, rub her back and wait. After a few minutes she looks at me.

You are such an asshole.

Fool Who Wants to Know and is ONLY HERE. The Alienist whispers to us softly inside. I almost forgot she's there. You came to me, but you do not need to stay. Never mind what I want from you. What do YOU want from ME?

I center myself. There will always be questions and more questions, next-level questions, revolutionary, galaxy-level questions, newly emerging realities and transcendent correspondences I'll never even recognize, no matter how close I may get or how much I want to understand. At least I know that much. Frannie is a wreck and I did it. I know that too.

I pull Frannie to me. You're the only thing I can't let go, I whisper to her. I'm so sorry, I'm done with her, I'll let all this go. I'm now crying more than Frannie is. Please forgive me, all of this shit is wrong. I'll never do it again. You lead, I follow.

Frannie silently keeps holding me as I heave and wail like a two-year-old into her neck. After a few unbearable minutes she sternly disengages from me and looks at me hard. Her face is tight and her eyes are dry. She keeps me fixed for another few seconds and then roughly pushes me away. She stands up and turns to The Alienist.

Fuck it. We want to know.

Yes. The Alienist sits completely immobile. You do. I am so sorry.

✦ ✦ ✦

IV.III Capacity

We return to the riverbank. Neither of us speak. We watch the current run this way close to shore and that way further out. Finally I reach for Frannie's hand. Two waves, one ocean, I whisper to her inside. Shut the fuck up, Frannie says out loud, and holds my hand tighter.

You never answered my question. The Alienist atop her broken chariot is right behind us.

You haven't answered ours either, Frannie growls at her.

My answer to your question about The Designer depends on how you answer mine. I need to first establish…your capacity.

Frannie's eyes narrow with fresh wrath. Which one is that, I ask quickly.

About what you do when a duality or trinity…

Doesn't fucking resolve. Frannie interrupts rudely.

Yes. The Alienist says. That one.

I wait for Frannie to answer but she remains silently steaming. It's clearly up to me to respond, so I do. Following just what we understand has been quite enough so far, I say. It's like recognizing and sifting out all the orphans in the bitfield who wanted to remain isolated. We let them go and push the doors we can open.

Yes. That seems sensible...with bits. The Alienist switches to speaking inside.

What about anything...existential?

Frannie groans in exasperation and looks away to contain her rekindling rage. I'm beginning to share it. I step directly in front of The Alienist.

My lady who is sometimes ONLY HERE, who has secrets you do not want and is burned by invisible marks. It seems we don't meet your expectations.

The Alienist remains unmoving and unreadable. No? She asks speaking outside.

You ask us about Grace and Intention. You ask us how we resolve the existential. You ask us to recognize dualities when we see them, as if we of all people might consider that a foreign concept. You evidently feel the need to test us.

Yes, The Alienist says. I do.

Frannie spins around and pushes me out of her way to glare ferociously at The Alienist. And yet you won't tell us what you want. How stupid do you think we are? Why test us if you don't want anything?

The Alienist does not respond. Two minutes, then five. She remains stony and silent. Frannie is staring at me hard with a giant what the fuck look. I can't blame her. I've had enough and break the spell.

What the hell are you so afraid of?

The Alienist immediately answers us inside, speaking slowly and soberly. You have asked the other right question. She leans forward to look us directly in the eye, and once again stands up, wraps falling away. She places her book on her seat and calmly removes her white cross and then her hat, laying them down carefully upon the book. She is completely bald. Frannie and I stagger as a sickening bolt of fear rips through us both. We scramble away as quickly as we can until Frannie stumbles backward. I manage to catch her just before she falls.

The Alienist gracefully steps down from the chariot and stands before it. Without her hat she is no taller than us. She is extremely thin and pale to the point of transparency. Her face has now grown weirdly mask-like, crawlingly cryptic and void except for her cavernous, glistening black eyes that seem independent from the rest of her.They are almost faces themselves. Her remaining wraps are no more than a shroud. There's barely twenty feet between this shockingly alien being shimmering before her useless chariot and us shaking in fear with our backs to the river.

She moves steadily closer, keeping constant eye contact with us while remaining completely unreadable. She seems ageless and ancient at the same time, overwhelmingly compelling, magnetically twisted. She is terrifying. I am nauseous with fear and yet completely fascinated. Frannie is becoming frantic again and screams something at me, fiercely trying to pull me away, but I am unable to move. The Alienist continues toward us and then stops directly in front of me. She slowly reaches out to take my hand, never taking her eyes off mine. She is ice cold. I'm only barely aware of Frannie sobbing and moving away.

You ask me my fear. The Alienist speaks to us inside, her formerly quiet voice now shockingly deep and resonant, no longer high and gentle, unleashing a new flame of terror through us. Her serenity remains unchanged.

I fear...The Designer.

She holds my hand for five long seconds before letting me go. No more tests, Fool Who Wants to Know and is ONLY HERE, she says softly in that disturbingly deep voice. Please walk with me. She turns to Frannie standing a few feet away, staring at us in horror. Both of you, please.

A footpath appears along the riverbank, leading to a small rock garden that had not been there before. The Alienist walks fixedly beside me, Frannie a few steps behind. She is petrified but stoically refusing to break down again. We are ONLY HERE, BE ONLY HERE, I urgently whisper to her inside. She can't hurt us. She's hurting us right now, you asshole, Frannie hotly thinks back to me. SHE IS THAT SOMETHING ELSE, I know it is, I know it is. WE DO NOT NEED TO BE HERE. WE DON'T NEED ANY OF THIS. Why don't you listen to me?

The Alienist does not intrude in our tense back and forth as she leads us to a small, semi-circular stone wall on the far side of the garden.

Please sit with me.

The three of us sit facing the river, me in the middle, The Alienist on my right, Frannie on my left, crushing my hand in a death grip. We silently watch the late afternoon sunlight glint off the water, the way it did just this morning when Frannie and I first saw it from up in the hills. The inner and outer currents of the river are still running in opposite directions. We are very much more elsewhere than ONLY HERE.

The Alienist turns to us, maintaining her deep, textured tone while switching back to her outside voice. You now see me as I see myself.

We have no words as we stare at the bald, hatless, utterly transfigured Alienist, her face an inflexible, inscrutable mask that hardly moves as she nods slightly to us. Only her glittering black eyes and dramatically lowered voice betray her ferocity.

Fool Who Wishes to Know and is ONLY HERE, your fear of me is quite unnecessary. I am not what you should be afraid of. I am not where your focus should be. Your focus should be on The Unmoving Hub and The Designer.

Frannie splutters in fresh disbelief as I finally find my voice. WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU?

I am The Alienist, of course. The Alienist who is ALWAYS HERE. I usually do not appear...this way. She attempts a small smile, making her mask-face even more chilling. Now then, please settle yourselves and I will further address your question, which is still a good one despite being based on fear. I will explain what you want to know, and then tell you what you need to know. Your marvelous CBM abilities should afford you a degree of...sympathetic resonance.

Are you fucking kidding me, Frannie erupts like a siren. The Unmoving Fucking Hub? How about Santa Claus or Rin Tin Tin?

The Alienist leans forward and bows her head to us, letting silence reassert itself as the echo of Frannie's outburst dies away. She speaks softly to us inside with a gentle kindness we have not felt from her before, made all the more compelling given the new depth and resonance in her voice. Know I am transparent with you, Dear Fool Who Wishes to Know and is ONLY HERE, as you are transparent with me, and as The Unmoving Hub is with all Creation. I will give you the proper context to ask correct questions, or at least good ones. Whether or not you see and understand is up to you and will be demonstrated by the questions you ask. She pauses as Frannie fights to collect herself, her hand even more rigidly clamped to mine than before. Her heart is rocketing in a high voltage wash of shock, confusion, anger, and more than a little fear. I have to be there for her, but I am obsessed by this shape-shifting, ethereal creature holding us fast on my right. I need to know what the hell is going on.

The Alienist looks at me as if she expects me to respond. I don't even know where to start. We...don't know what you're talking about, I somehow manage to stammer.

Of course you don't, The Alienist doesn't move a muscle but still conveys a shrug. No one can truly anticipate let alone understand...every duality, especially if one doesn't ask...the right questions. That's the point, isn't it? Let us renew that process now.

I struggle to concentrate on what she's saying as Frannie beside me remains borderline ballistic, ready to blow. The Alienist switches to speaking to us outside in her new magnetic voice. Parts but not all of her speech are clearly well-practiced, yet I somehow know she is also completely in the moment, reaching out to us from whatever constitutes her heart.

We are all designed to perform a function, usually more than one. In executing those functions we activate ourselves as borders. You know that. I was primarily designed to function as an advisor. In that capacity I am available to those who are SOMEWHAT HERE. I attempt to help them know themselves as The Unmoving Hub knows them, albeit in a quite distant, indirect, simplistic way. To do so I often apply strains of analogy and adjacency that I believe you would appreciate. At the same time, I also perform that function as closely as possible in the opposite direction, allowing The Hub to see itself through the lives of those damaged, unstable, fragile, tenuous beings, saturated with love, fear, desperation, and hardly a drop of true understanding. Not really.

Now to simple, honest seekers, I appear in variations of the form you first encountered. My bearing, my crown – it is not a "hat" – my book and my chariot are all touchstones for the traveler. Each element is...intentionally designed. My current, unadorned form is of course also intentionally designed, but it is the most reflective of the aspect of me that is...ALWAYS HERE, and far less...intermittent. In this form I perform a range of...other functions, which do not concern you at the moment. What does concern you is that this is the form I use to speak to you now, in this moment, Fool Who Wants to Know, is ONLY HERE and Who Passes My Tests. You are therefore in rare company, even though countless others have passed my tests before you, and countless more will do so after you. I appear in whatever form is the most effective and efficient for the seeker, so that they may join the rest of us, together, all of us ONLY HERE, in whatever manner and to whatever extent as Grace allows, even for just one moment.

I feel Frannie leveling off to a mere simmering fury, but at least she's listening. The Alienist continues speaking to us outside in her deep, unnerving voice. She maintains her gentle tone but steadily grows annoyingly pedantic.

Let's return to familiar if not necessarily fertile ground. You must push yourselves to surpass the limited understanding of your dog and Transformed Worker. They know what they know of The ONE and The Unmoving Hub, but they do not know of The Designer or THE OTHER. This is what you must remember: Only The Designer can create the ten thousand things, using the materia prima given to him by Grace from THE OTHER who holds The One's Fields of Perpetual Potential, Precision, and Correspondence. The Designer is distinct from The One, The Hub, and THE OTHER. I would think you would know that by now, but you must actively center it. As you will see, that distinction is the crux of the matter, but to properly understand that we must begin with The Unmoving Hub.

I jump in before Frannie does. Wait a minute, hold on. That whole Unmoving Hub business is just an old myth or superstition. That's what The Worker Transformed said.

Did she? The Alienist turns quizzical. Perhaps because you are children you preferred to hear it that way. I'm quite sure even your dog, let alone your Transformed Worker, knows without a doubt The Unmoving Hub is Reality Itself. That said, one of your Transformed Worker's most evolved qualities is her awareness of her limitations. For example, it doesn't appear as if she would differentiate between The Unmoving Hub and The Designer at all, despite her focus on Intention, let alone on dualities and trinities. Certainly you dog never made...that leap. Neither of them have your capacity to understand. But none of that matters. Unless you keep a dual focus on The Unmoving Hub and The Designer, you will not ask...the right questions. I urge you to keep that perspective.

Who the fuck does she think she is, talking like that, Frannie whispers to me with hammer-like intensity.

And so, The Alienist resumes, now speaking inside. You asked me what I am, and I have answered. I rarely share so much. This is enough of what you want to know. The Alienist's eyes turn incandescent. Now this is what you need to know. She pauses for a few moments to ensure unwavering eye contact with us before switching back to speaking outside.

I told you I fear The Designer, but to know my fear you must understand not only his origin and function, but also the origin of The Unmoving Hub itself. I will explain all, and you will understand. For now, please retain and center the Four Narrative Truths:

  1. In the beginning there was The One.
  2. For reasons unknowable and unspeakable, and some would say calamitous, The One created THE OTHER, an exact copy of itself.
  3. The Designer was born of necessity in the space between The One and THE OTHER.
  4. For reasons unknowable and unspeakable, and some would say miraculous, The One became The Unmoving Hub, the Center of All Chance and All Creation.

Frannie buries her face in her hands and rips into me inside. Are you hearing this insanity? This is such bullshit. Why the fuck are we here?

The Alienist spares me having to answer by continuing her testimony. I will speak to The One's descent from All to So Much Less, but in order for you to surface the proper context, we will focus on The Designer and his function first. It will make sense once you have the full story.

Not if I kill myself first, Frannie seethes loudly and bares her teeth. The Alienist doesn't care and doesn't stop. She is now rhapsodic.

The Designer is the brilliant and exalted artist, interpreter and activator of the unrealized Fields of Perpetual Potential, Precision, and Correspondence made available via THE OTHER, the true and complete copy of The One. You will see. The Designer articulates all that we know and can ever know in this and all the worlds – all Creation, absolutely everything – as manifestations of The One and in loving service to The One. Without The Designer, The One and THE OTHER would remain eternally ignorant of what they are, and no beings such as us would exist to reflect and manifest The One's perfect love.

Frannie interrupts, clearly near the end of her patience. My blusterous lady, can you even hear yourself right now?

The Alienist responds wearily. All too well, Fool Who Wants to Know and is ONLY HERE, just as I can hear millions of others who know what I know and live as I live, in constant fear of what The Designer has become. I need you to listen. She takes a deep breath for strength before continuing.

Since before the beginning of time, The Designer has performed his function immaculately and intentionally in Loving Service to The Unmoving Hub. By Grace he delights in what he spins out, knowing those creations are all rapturous manifestations of The One Itself. That is...no longer the case.

WHY NOT? Frannie spits back impatiently. The Alienist closes her eyes and sucks in her breath. A horrific shudder rips through her tiny body.

Because he's lost his mind, The Alienist replies softly. The Designer is now insane, and as a result is extremely dangerous. Existentially dangerous. She opens her eyes and peers deeply into ours.

Hear me, Fool Who Wishes to Know and is ONLY HERE. The Designer has more than lost his way. He literally believes he's God. Through a long, traceable, and compounding series of ruptures along primordial faultlines, The Designer no longer differentiates himself from The One who is now The Unmoving Hub. He retains all his previous power and vision to spin out the ten thousand things, but by doing so he now believes he is manifesting himself. He now believes he is The Source of The Perfect Love that is The One, instead of merely being its agent.

And just as he has the power to create the infinite forms, the formless, and the rest of it, he also has the power to destroy. Since he is the one who spins out the ten thousand things, actualizing the unknown into the known, he can also unspin all existence into non-existence.

You must understand. The Designer has the power to end all Creation with a single, consciously articulated thought, a single intention. In his newly developed but complete insanity, he can instantly destroy everything we know or could ever know as Creation in this world and in all the worlds. With just a shadow of active intention, the insane Designer can even destroy The Unmoving Hub. He can break it all, instantly, in one single flash of focused madness.

She takes my hand once again in her icy one and speaks to us deep inside.

THAT'S why I fear The Designer.

✦ ✦ ✦

The Alienist holds my right hand for a long ten seconds before gently letting me go. Frannie stares at her for a few moments and then drops my left hand in disgust. No one speaks. I don't know how to process this, but somehow I know The Alienist is both completely crazy and also speaking the truth. The three of us sit silently and watch the river.

Frannie's anger refires, her self-control holding as tenuously as morning fog before dawn. She shakes her head, stands up and turns to face The Alienist. Her voice is low and measured but her wrath is unmistakable.

You need to start at the beginning. We keep hearing about this Unmoving Hub of yours, The One, THE OTHER, the whatever. I will never understand why people have to make up stories like this and then pretend they're real, like really real. Everyone knows these stories are at best a compounding chain of analogies, at worst a load of complete bullshit hiding some evil agenda. Whatever your motivation, however sincerely you believe it, you're just piling one fairy tale on top of another, while none of it, ZERO, has a single foundation in fact. What happened to requiring a little thing called proof before choosing to freak yourself out, and then fucking with everyone else's head?

The Alienist doesn't respond, and I don't want to argue with Frannie. We just stare at her, and Frannie stares right back at us, more in disbelief than in anger. She cannot see what I see.

COME ON with all this, Frannie fumes. She looks at me hard. You know I'm right! I mean, people can tell themselves ANYTHING and talk themselves into believing it, and then it's off to the races. Idiots do that all the time, but we aren't idiots! There's no proof! How can you just believe... Frannie's words trail off, letting her glare finish her sentence for her.

The Alienist allows the ensuing silence to land and spread before responding. The proof is everywhere, she says quietly. Everything is a manifestation of The Unmoving Hub.

Frannie pushes right back. Saying that does not make it true.

Blaise Pascal holding playing cardsAnd your blindness does not make a difference.16 Fool, how can you not know that by now. I will explain, not argue. There is so much you do not understand. You could at least learn your inability to believe.17 The Alienist closes her eyes and forces herself to breathe deeply.

Please, Frannie, BE HERE with me on this, I beg her inside. She looks at me in a boil of rage and contempt. Don't you even, she hisses back.

The Alienist opens her eyes and wearily stands to face Frannie. Fool Who Wants to Know, is ONLY HERE and Still Demands Proof, your disrespect for The Unmoving Hub is astonishing, as is your determination to remain an isolated orphan when you are surrounded by The Sacred. I pray you will one day open your heart, but for now, I merely ask you to sit down and listen. There is much for me to explain and for you to understand.

Frannie remains standing and keeps her eyes locked into The Alienist's. No problem, she says in a low growl. There's much for everyone to understand. Yet some of us listen more intentionally than others. Is that not your experience? She turns and calmly sits next to me without another word.

The Alienist standing is only slightly taller than the two of us sitting, but she still manages to look down on us, radiating both impatience and resolve. Fool Who Wants to Know, is ONLY HERE and Still Demands Proof, hear me now. Your addiction to proof reveals your deficiency of context. That is somewhat to be expected. I do sometimes forget you are children and cannot always see what's right in front of you. And so I will take your suggestion to start at the beginning and speak to you of The One's Original Sin, which ultimately led to The Madness of The Designer. You will either see or you won't see, but either way there will be transparency between us. Compulsion is superfluous.18 Frannie recoils in revulsion.

Kneeling Thutmose III figure before the High PriestessThe Alienist then kneels before us and takes both our hands in her frigid ones. As being is to becoming, so is truth to belief, she whispers to us inside.19 Think of me what you will, Fool, but know this above all else: I do not lie.

✦ ✦ ✦

IV.IV The Right Questions, Original Sin, and Madness

The One's Original Sin

The Alienist releases our hands. She stands but remains directly in front of us and uncomfortably close, forcing us to maintain unwavering eye contact with her. Please stay seated, she says in her deep, resonant outside voice. Her face remains pure mask.

A split-second, bizarre flash abruptly overwhelms me. The Alienist's radiant black eyes are now strikingly diamond-shaped. She's staring intensely at me from deep below the earth, as if she's reaching up and out from a lost and ancient cave miles underground, holding me fast through tons of solid rock. And then it's over, the vision is gone. The tiny Alienist is standing right in front of Frannie and me. She looks no more abnormal than she did ten seconds ago.

Where the fuck did you just go, Frannie whispers angrily inside to me, demanding an answer, but I'm too disoriented and disconnected to respond. She turns away darkly muttering thanks, whatever. My heart reels and I flail uselessly after her as The Alienist chooses that exact moment to launch into a fresh landslide of lecture and sermon.

The Unmoving Hub manifests in all things, but before time and borders existed, there was no Unmoving Hub. There was only The One, and The One was ALL. There was no above and below, there were no dualities, there was only The One. Somehow The One became conscious, aware of itself and its existence, although it is not known how or why. Perhaps you shall explore that unfathomable mystery in time. But since The One was all there was, The One could learn nothing about itself and could not see itself, because there was nothing BUT itself. It did not know what it was. It only knew it existed.20

So The One created space within itself, and with nothing else to work with, filled that space with a copy of itself and brought that copy forth, thereby creating THE OTHER.21 Now The One could see itself from the perspective of THE OTHER. But as THE OTHER was a copy of The One, they were exactly the same. Neither knew what it was looking at since there was no frame of reference. The One had essentially multiplied its problem when it divided itself. The One and THE OTHER were conscious of nothing else except that now two of them existed, whereas before only The One existed. They were equally unknowable to themselves and unknowable to each other.

And so from necessity, The Designer emerged between The One and THE OTHER to fashion the infinite forms of Creation, born of the unrealized Fields of Perpetual Potential, Precision, and Correspondence The One inherently carries within itself, the identical fields now mirrored and made accessible by Grace from within THE OTHER. And so you see, because everything fashioned by The Designer is sourced from THE OTHER, an exact copy of The One, everything fashioned by The Designer was, is, and always will be, a direct manifestation of The One.

These are the First Three of the Four Narrative Truths.

The Alienist steps slightly back and crosses her translucent, stick-like arms in front of her, as if waiting for us to acknowledge this flawless presentation of the apparently obvious. Frannie and I remain silent. I'm deeply processing but after a minute Frannie disengages and leans slightly toward The Alienist. Bullshit, she says slowly and quietly.

The Alienist shifts her gaze and focuses directly on me, speaking to me inside and pointedly disregarding Frannie. In this respect, The One is like you, she says in her deep voice. It wants to know. By encountering the forms wrought by The Designer, and allowing the ten thousand things to resonate within itself, The One perpetually gains an ever-deepening knowledge of itself. She takes a deep breath and keeps her eyes locked with mine for a few more seconds. It ALWAYS wants to know. Just like you. She stays dug into me for another long moment before looking away.

Frannie snaps. Oh my god, somebody help me, she screams inside. What the absolute fuck is she talking about?

I don't know, but please Frannie, let her finish and then we'll figure it out, we always do. Frannie bores into me, incensed and unshackled. This is all complete bullshit, and you fucking know it. She wants something from us. What is wrong with you?

Unfazed by our distress, The Alienist steps forward again to stand directly in front of us and intentionally way too close. We will continue, she intones.

The One, in effect, now had someone to talk to. THE OTHER enabled The Designer to present The One with endless and often astonishing forms and reflections of itself. Frannie sighs heavily and The Alienist cocks her head at her. No more interruptions, Fool Who Demands Proof, she chides briskly. Your rudeness makes no difference. I will explain, not argue.

At that point The One functionally became The Unmoving Hub, enshrining the last of the Four Narrative Truths. Its copy, THE OTHER, settled into its satellite role, eternally orbiting The One, now The Unmoving Hub, with The Designer raised up and operating in the space between the two. And ever since, and even now in his madness, The Designer continues to spin out infinite forms pulled from THE OTHER in manifestation of The Unmoving Hub. They are the existential Trinity, the Three that is One that is Three.

The Alienist regards us once again as junior high dolts she's tutoring in advance of a geometry exam. And so, you can see, if you know how to look, that Creation does not just reflect The Unmoving Hub. Creation ultimately exists only IN SERVICE TO THE HUB and its ever-deepening understanding of itself as The One.

The Alienist pauses. Now obviously The Designer's insanity creates some immediate and terrifying instability – we will speak more of that shortly – but beyond that, and using The Four Narrative Truths as your frame, I take it you see both the obvious as well as the larger problems here.

Frannie and I stare at each other and then back to The Alienist. Frannie sneers at her. I'm looking at the obvious problem right now. Are you really asking us which steaming pile of crap you just dumped on us reeks the most? I quickly step in front of Frannie and cut her off before she unloads further on The Alienist. I'm not...sure we do, I answer slowly.

The Alienist looks at us closely. Your childishness is abhorrent but your confusion is...truly surprising. It's fairly basic...arithmetic. She continues to stare at us. No matter, I am no longer testing you. I will explain, and you will see quickly.

The One was ALL before it created the space within itself from which THE OTHER was brought forth, an exact copy of itself. THE OTHER was therefore born from an act of division, yes? Or if you'd rather think holistically, by replicating itself and then bringing that copy forth into separate but identical existence, The One simultaneously multiplied AND divided itself in the same act! Where there was one, there was now two. One multiplied by two equals two, but one divided by two is also two – two halves. The Alienist pauses to look at us carefully to make sure we follow her advanced calculations. We stare back at her. We understand, Frannie grumbles through clenched teeth.

No, you do not, The Alienist says evenly, apparently musing to herself. You do not understand. Perhaps you never will, although that is unlikely. After all, you do want to know, and you are truly ONLY HERE. She looks at us thoughtfully and then slowly closes her eyes. Grace does indeed pick its spots, she whispers. So be it. She fully opens her glistening black eyes and bears down on us intently. We will continue. I will prepare you to recognize the obvious. Stay with me, Fool.

A sudden, crushing wave of The Alienist's agonizing suffering engulfs us, erupting en masse from her thousands of excruciating, invisible marks. Her mask-like face remains completely blank and unchanging as we stagger beneath the deluge of pain and unfathomable sadness she forces us to share. She nods slightly in acknowledgment of our gasps of shock and reflexive empathy, the rush of ONLY HERE. We push our love as hard as we can into the black abyss roiling inside The Alienist, but any light from us is overwhelmed by her unrelenting interior darkness. She allows a full, brutal minute of tortuous transference to pass before reclaiming her inner hell and terminating our access. She remains masked and expressionless the entire time.

Frannie and I are both hollowed-out and horror-stricken, but she is also disgusted and repelled. I'm as shattered as Frannie, but I'm also twistedly bewitched by The Alienist's chaotic mystery and relentless, spiraling madness, even as I become increasingly nauseous and unsteady from being in such prolonged and intimate contact with her. She is terrifyingly monstrous to Frannie but monstrously compelling to me, and thoroughly toxic to us both. But I can't care about that now.

I can no more explain my burning need to understand The Alienist as I can overcome it. She told us she does not lie, and I believe that. She told us she was not what we should be afraid of, and although I have no idea what she means, I believe that as well. Then she told us layer upon layer of insane quasi-spiritual claptrap that Frannie quite understandably calls bullshit, but that is nonetheless opening doors for me I never knew existed. Everything is floundering inside as I grapple with The Alienist's unfathomable pain, power, and sheer otherness. I'm sick with the need to know. My stomach keels further as I realize Frannie is shutting herself off and moving far away from me.

The Alienist calmly pushes on, resuming her pedantic tone as if she is still instructing five-year-olds.

You must maintain your focus. I have explained how The One came to function as The Unmoving Hub, how THE OTHER orbits the Hub, and how the Designer operates from the space between the two. All of this came to be because The One had to know. But as per our many marks, both yours and mine, we understand knowledge is never freely given, not even to The One. The attainment of knowledge always exacts a price.

Now for you to finally see the obvious problem, we must step back and take careful note: where once The One had been ALL, now both The One and THE OTHER were each LESS THAN ONE, LESS THAN ALL.22 Where there had once been unity, there was now duality. So follow me now. Duality cannot exist without separation, which means...The Alienist pauses as if waiting for us to complete the sentence, but we remain silent. Oh my dear Fool, where there is now separation between The One and THE OTHER, by definition there are also now borders, yes? For both The One and THE OTHER, there was now an Inside and an Outside. Most crucially, there was also now SPACE OUTSIDE OF THEM BOTH – we shall return to the profound ramifications of that soon enough.

The Alienist softens her tone as if to walk us gingerly over even more challenging conceptual terrain. Surely you've recognized there are now borders between The Unmoving Hub, THE OTHER, and the space outside of them both, yes? When The One was All, the concept of borders would have been completely meaningless. That is so apparent you simply didn't think about it, I can see that. But now that you are thinking about it, you must surely recognize the Creation of the First Borders as a most transcendent, transformational development. Everything from then on was stamped by duality, revealing borders as expressions and passageways of unspeakable beauty and Perfect Love, with Grace choosing its spots. Here is this and there is that, and yet, there is unity behind that duality. You of all beings certainly know that. However, for uncountable numbers of others, borders are not passageways. They are obstructions. They create profound confusion and disunity. Borders are a dynamic, catalytic framework for those like you, but for others they often function as soul-crushing, festering marks of contradiction, separation and isolation.

And so, The Alienist concludes, her condescension finally peaking, I frame this for you now as the existential and completely obvious problem, if one can call it that, of The Designer's insanity. Is that not so?

Frannie snorts in contempt. There is no lack of the obvious with you, but OK fine, we now have borders because these two make-believe, all-or-nothing bubbles split into two when there had previously only been one. The first Venn Diagram was born.23 So what?

The Alienist shakes her head in disbelief. Fear is so destructive. I do not believe you are fearful at heart, Fool Who Demands Proof. In fact I know it is quite the opposite. But you must learn to more effectively recalibrate. I will continue to address the levels within you that allow themselves to hear.

Separation and borders exemplify the larger problem. Do you still not understand? It is no matter. I will explain, and you will see the larger problem is also obvious once you allow yourselves to look, although I quite understand your reluctance to do so. It is as simple as it is...astoundingly distressing. The Alienist covers her face with her hands and moans in pain, taking several deep, tiny-body-shaking breaths. Frannie has moved well away from me, but despite our distance from each other we can only stare in aghast wonder once again at this severely broken, possessed alien being. We force ourselves not to be taken away by her immense suffering. Her voice is still quaking when she's steady enough to continue.

Two distinct circles — borders between The One, THE OTHER, and The OutsideOnce The One created THE OTHER, the REALITY OF ALL ceased to exist. The ALL could only exist within The Undivided One, when The One was indeed ALL. Surely you can see that as a result of The One's Original Sin the objective reality of THE ALL was now permanently destroyed. At best only a fairly useless and purely theoretical concept of THE ALL remains, inaccessible and irrelevant to most beings. If explained to them, most would agree the basic idea is useless, and pursuing the idea utterly stupid.

Whoever would possibly think that, Frannie deadpans.

Beings who blissfully lack your capacity would think that, The Alienist replies icily. You and I and countless others who are ONLY HERE do not have that luxury. Now stop interrupting. As a result of The One needing to know, now NOTHING IS ALL, and NOTHING CAN BE ALL. Before the One needed to know, EVERYTHING WAS ONE, and ONE WAS ALL. Now ALLNESS can never exist again. The One broke it when it broke itself to create THE OTHER and then become The Unmoving Hub. What we know as Creation was miraculously brought forth by Grace from that breakage, but at the cost of THE ALL's destruction.

The Alienist shudders convulsively but quickly regathers herself. She unleashes a single, withering rush of her hellish inner despair to wrack us again, and then bores her blazing black eyes into Frannie's, straining to keep her voice steady. The essential truths in what you dismiss as mere mythologies and creation stories speak to the fundamental reality underpinning the realms of quantum physics and ever-evolving cosmologies. The watermark of duality is stamped on everything whether you see that or not. DNA itself manifests duality. But know this, Fool, and center it in your heart. If there is NO ALL, there is NO ANYTHING.

What?! Frannie explodes at The Alienist. LISTEN TO YOURSELF! When will you fucking stop already?

The Alienist's eyes shine an even fiercer fire of blackness.

Every particle of what we think of as Creation is marked and broken by its fundamental dualities, because The One is marked and broken by its self-inflicted duality, when its need to know became so overwhelming it created THE OTHER. That's why The Unmoving Hub can only serve the CONCEPT OF ALL, because THE REALITY OF ALL no longer exists. The ten thousand things still return to The One. But because of its Original Sin, The One has nowhere to return to. The One is Not The Only, but it's The Only One it has, the Only One WE have!

HEAR ME AND CENTER THIS, FOOL! ONLY HERE is ONLY HERE, but what is ONLY HERE if not all of Creation's collective unconscious, cosmic memory, the resonance of all beings with The One before its Original Sin, its intentional and disastrous division of itself? When we are ONLY HERE, WE ARE ONLY THERE. We ecstatically become ghosts in a place that no longer exists. So do you STILL truly not see the problem?

Frannie turns her back on The Alienist and thinks furiously to me. How much more of this shit do you need? I desperately want to respond, but before I can The Alienist cries out again, unable to contain herself any longer. She sobs uncontrollably, her mask twisting and contorting in agony.

Fool, why are you forcing me to spell this out? When we are ONLY HERE, and ONLY ONLY HERE, we are ONE, WE ARE ALL, yes? Is that not how it feels, is that not HOW IT IS? Is that not the most REAL thing there is? Now get past yourself already and recognize a trick when you see one, especially when you play it on yourself! When we are so joyously ONLY HERE, we force The Unmoving Hub to relive its Original Sin! By being ONLY HERE we inhabit a space that NO LONGER EXISTS. ONLY HERE IS A LIE!

Frannie stares open-mouthed in shock at The Alienist; I feel myself doing the same. She has now completely lost her mind, and she's not stopping.

And yet it is so much worse than that! NONE of this is about you, it's not about me, or about any of the millions of beings who understand this. By continually inflicting the lie of ONLY HERE on The Unmoving Hub, we are threatening its very existence! The Unmoving Hub is already only half of what it was before it foolishly created THE OTHER. How much more do you think it can take? Beings like me who understand this do not know if The Unmoving Hub can survive the constant torture of our being ONLY HERE. Can you even begin to understand that? Ultimately this threatens all Creation even more than Insane Designer does, because we can and will replace him. Again I say to you: The One may not be The Only, but it is the Only One we have!

Frannie berates me as we lock eyes. I fucking told you: she is Darkness upon Darkness. You really want to know? THERE IT FUCKING IS. IF ONLY HERE is a LIE, then WE ARE A LIE. IS THAT WHAT YOU THINK?

I'm petrified and paralyzed. Of course not, how can you say that, I somehow manage to whisper. NEVER MIND, Frannie slams the door on me. I will recalibrate the living shit out of you later.

The Alienist is no longer sobbing. She watches me crumble before Frannie and then quietly speaks to us inside. Now you understand, finally. Look what it took. Perhaps you have heard a house divided against itself shall not stand. That is quite correct. One, in effect, no longer equals One. That, dear Fool, is the larger problem.

Frannie keeps her eyes locked into mine. I feel her strength gathering and thrusting to the surface. I got this, she thunders to me inside. You just shut the fuck up.

Frannie stands up and plants herself directly before the now fully recovered Alienist. All right, that's quite enough, she says slowly, quietly, and pointedly without anger. I have listened and listened and listened to you. I doubt you will ever listen to me or anyone else as carefully. I in no way doubt your pain or your sincerity. I pray you will one day find peace. But you have been alone for a very long time. The only voice you hear is your own, endlessly booming and echoing within your own head. After barely withstanding that voice for only a few hours, I cannot imagine the absolute hell of constantly existing with that riot raging within you. Now listen if you can:

You talk about your book being a mirror. Do you have a real one you can use sometime? You need to take a good long look. You are giving yourself your own marks! I don't believe your stories are real, but I'll play along to make a point. Of course The One is Not The Only! ONLY HERE IS ONLY HERE. That's the ONLY, the ONLY ONLY! This nonsense about "The All", "The One", all that stuff is at best mental scaffolding nobody needs. You just talk yourself into all this pain with all that crap, but you can stop anytime. ONLY HERE IS ONLY HERE. No crazy story, no hat, no tests needed.

Frannie looks at me sharply before continuing. Now to the rest of it. We're not afraid of something being "Outside", whatever the hell that means. You know so much about us, right? Then you know when we were in the bitfield we were on the very borders of both The Outside and the Unknown Beneath The Bottom! We didn't know what was out there or down there, but we didn't have to know and we still don't! We just had to do what we knew how to do, and it worked out. So you know what that means? We're not like you, that's what it means. We don't have your insane problems. We don't think we know everything, but we know what we know. Maybe that makes us a Fool, but I'd rather be a Fool than totally fucked up and dark like you.

The Alienist cuts Frannie off. I have learned to expect your insolence, but your ignorance continues to amaze me. I urge you to recall the wisdom of your beloved Transformed Worker as you refuse to open your heart and hear me. Even if you do not wish to believe me when I speak of The One and everything else, please understand the arithmetic I am trying to teach you is an analogy, albeit a rather precise one. Open your mind, Fool. You admit you do not know everything. I am speaking to you about Ultimate Reality, about Creation, of your own face before you were born.

Frannie arches back from The Alienist with a classic Frannie eyeroll. Interesting you mention The Worker Transformed. Unlike you, she was able to listen! Unlike you, she took real steps to fix herself! She came to learn to let go of her own craziness, accept Grace when it was offered, and then grow into her own salvation. Maybe you can give that a try sometime.

The Alienist stays locked into Frannie's eyes all through her screed and for a full minute after she stops. Finally The Alienist nods at her, drops her eyes and bows her head.

The second line of consciousness — Strength, The Hermit, Wheel of Fortune, Justice, The Hanged Man, Death, Temperance

Dear Fool Who Wants to Know, is ONLY HERE and Still Demands Proof, you have spoken well, and I do hear you, The Alienist says quietly. I know you speak from your heart and your strength. Your vision is true for you, and what else can one ask for? May your own path remain that easy. May you always be ONLY, ONLY HERE. May Grace hold you to her bosom forever. I believe your design will prove to be slightly...more challenging...you will find out. But whether you care to believe me or not, remember this above all: I do not lie.

Frannie remains standing directly in front of The Alienist, but I see her rage begin to taper. She does not look at me.

The Alienist continues to speak softly in dramatic contrast to the bludgeoning tirade she had just inflicted upon us. I do not share my marks with you to cause you pain. I share my marks to make you listen.

Everything I told you about The One becoming The Unmoving Hub, THE OTHER, and The Designer is real. My design as an advisor to the SOMEWHAT HERE is also real, if anything all too real. I meet all beings who find me where they are, including you two. That is real as well. My appearing to you in this form should be proof enough. You will learn in accordance with your limitations, as will we all.

Frannie nods slowly and keeps her voice low and totally under control. Your marks are the only thing about you I believe. Everything else, you can go fuck yourself.

The Alienist bows her head again to Frannie, and also keeps her voice low and steady. We do not align, Fool. So be it. I recognize this as a source of heat for you, and will leave that for you to manage as you will.

Frannie mockingly bows back to The Alienist and then turns to me. Are we done now? Our strange friend's crises of faith and monsters under her bed are her problem, not ours. Also please pardon me for intruding upon your coma. I don't need your weak-ass backup, but when you come to you might want to ask her who the fuck she thinks she is to tell us or anyone else what ONLY HERE means. Give me a fucking break.

I can't answer her. Of course she's right, Frannie's always right. I give her everything I can and hold her tight inside, and she instantly takes me back while remaining completely stony. My mind is racing. Everything Frannie and The Alienist are saying resonates with me, but I also sense elements neither one of them can see. It's all coming together quickly but it's not quite there, not yet.

Once again The Alienist ignores the tension between Frannie and me, and addresses us both inside. Uncomfortably for both of us, there is more to discuss. What neither of you can ignore is the Madness of The Designer. Recall once again your Transformed Worker – none of this is about you. No work is optional on a ship in rough seas.

Frannie groans and rubs her eyes. There's more, she mutters. Of course there's more. There's always more. She slowly sits back down and roughly takes my hand without looking at me. I wish she would stop quoting her, I think to Frannie. Shut the fuck up, she thinks back as The Alienist starts up again.

The Madness of The Designer

All Creation is the work of The Designer. Nothing other than the diminished One, the equally diminished OTHER, and the space around them would exist without him. The Designer fashions the ten thousand things, the formed, the formless, and all the rest. The Designer activates the infinite creativity latent within THE OTHER, and by his work enables The One to know itself and thereby be ever renewed as The Unmoving Hub. You now understand that.

Yes, yes, yes, how many times do you have to keep beating us to death with all that, says Frannie. I understood you every time. I don't believe a word of it, you believe all of it, and who knows what the hell is going on with this one, she says cocking her head toward me. OK fine, that's where we are. But even if you're right and I'm wrong and it's all true, how do you know? I ask you again, where is your proof?

The Alienist leans forward and speaks gently to Frannie. I choose to believe you speak from your heart and not from your fear, Fool Who Wants to Know, is ONLY HERE, Who Passes My Tests. and Still Demands Proof. You choose to stay with me because you yearn for what you distantly know but will not allow yourself to see. So be it. The hardest borders to cross are the ones we create around ourselves. I would think you two would know that by now. But it is no matter. However much you fight me, my faith in you is not misplaced. I tell you again Fool, the proof is everywhere. Your very being is proof.

I remain silent. I find myself unable to pay attention to the back and forth between the maddening Alienist and the temporarily dialed back Frannie, who is finally holding my hand without crushing it. I'm of course still ONLY HERE but am increasingly drawn SOMEWHERE ELSE. An indistinct, swirlingly opaque presence rises up from below to meet me, as a hidden shoreline might appear through the mist to a hawk searching for somewhere solid to land. Deep, transcendently familiar and living chords of thunder roll over me from above, proclaiming the way through sparkling glints and beacons of starlight. Above and below ignite in rapturous, now-you-see-it, now-you-don't affirmation that Frannie and I will lead and follow each other to live a truth The Alienist will never know, even though the only way there is directly through her.

Frannie snaps me back with a firm shove. Would you like to come back from wherever the hell you just went and join the rest of the class, she says mirthlessly. We're ready for the next revelation from our chilly little friend here. The Alienist nods gratuitously to us, seemingly unaware that I'm still very much wrapped up in this bewildering and beautiful vision of Frannie and me, above and below, MORE ONLY HERE THAN ONLY HERE CAN BE. I can barely feel the garden's stone wall I'm still somehow sitting on, Frannie on my left and The Alienist on my right. Frannie lets me lean against her even though I know she wants to kill me. Let us now speak of The Designer, The Alienist says, and is off once again.

Unlike The One who in mystery came to self-awareness, The Designer has always been self-aware. He is one with his function. He always rejoices in his work, but over time he has, shall we say, lost his perspective. He has come to believe much of what his creations tell themselves about him. So many of my marks come from the foolish conceptions endless generations of humans and other beings assault me with about The Designer and The Unmoving Hub. Very few make a distinction between the two. It is this misguided conflation of The Designer with The Unmoving Hub that has so warped The Designer's understanding of himself.

I am so sick of this shit, Frannie moans as I am coming to. I need to know where The Alienist is going. I pull myself off Frannie and force her to look at me. Listen listen listen I beg her. She angrily turns away, but keeps her hand in mine. I feel The Alienist waiting for us to resettle before she resumes.

Three of Pentacles — craftsman presenting work to two figures in a cathedralThe Designer is particularly enchanted by human beings, many of whom are convinced they are fashioned in The Designer's own image, which is obviously ridiculous. In truth anything eternal within them comes from The Unmoving Hub via THE OTHER, and is only delivered by The Designer. Many humans and other beings sense their link with The Unmoving Hub, but they do not pay sufficient attention. They do not do the necessary work to discover where that ultimate self-knowledge truly comes from. As a result, their conscious but cloudy bit of Oneness remains vague and malleable, tragically leading many to mistake the Perfect Love that radiates from The Hub as coming from The Designer. He now believes those childish ideas about him are true.

Now make no mistake: The Designer is indeed exalted and integral as he serves within the space between The Hub and THE OTHER, fashioning The Hub's love and endless energy into this form, that form, endless forms. The Designer gives shape to the miracle of existence manifesting the Underlying Love underpinning all Creation, but that love and energy do not come from him! Nonetheless, most humans and other beings don't know that, and tragically now neither does he. Humans and other beings have created exquisitely beautiful systems and stories, poems, songs and rituals all ascribing Perfection and Goodness to The Designer, who has now come to believe that of himself. He has forgotten his place. And yet, so much of what he designs is indeed unspeakably beautiful and transcendent, full of love, and as you well know, intentional through Grace. Yet somehow spinning out the ten thousand things from between The One and THE OTHER is no longer enough for The Designer.

The Alienist pauses and looks directly at us. Now as you can imagine, The Designer's insanity leads to… consequences.

Consequences, Frannie repeats flatly. That's one word for it. Doesn't he also design the Dark?

Yes and no, The Alienist replies. The Dark has always been present as the duality of The Light. Light and Dark are the first of countless other dualities indelibly etched into everything brought forth by The Designer. Light and Dark are fused together within the unrealized Fields of Perpetual Potential, Precision, and Correspondence copied from The One to THE OTHER. That fundamental, inescapable duality serves as the Eternal Mark of The One's Original Sin. And so, dualities such as Light and Dark permeate every fiber of the cosmic material The Designer draws upon to spin out the ten thousand things.

Oh yeah, that's right, Frannie mumbles with annoyance. What was I thinking...

The Alienist bows slightly to Frannie and continues. You are not wholly wrong, Fool. Originally The Light and The Dark were in balance, as you must always remember. From the beginning, The Dark was always present and painful, inevitably following The Light like a shadow. From the beginning there have always been two sides of the knife, handle and blade, irrevocably marking all self-aware beings throughout their lives. However, The Designer's insanity caused The Dark to explode disproportionally and become twisted and warped, exponentially darker, more prominent and damning than it had been before when it was purely a point of balance to The Light. The Dark has now mutated into Pure Evil, which was never a part of the original Light/Dark duality. Over the eons The Designer's madness has caused The Dark to grow even beyond the point of sadism, generating ever more needless pain and suffering in both scope and weight, and it is getting worse. And so now, due to that horrific imbalance of Dark over Light, almost all self-aware beings become nothing but their marks if they live long enough. A life of unending marks is now the ongoing cost of consciousness for human beings and others like them. Most have quite limited capacity to withstand the onslaught. Frannie and I instantly flash to the memory of The Lightless Moon telling us the same thing in The Worker Transformed's garden.

And so, The Alienist sighs as she sits down once again next to me. All that exponentially greater pain, all that fear, all that unnecessary, pointless suffering, all that pathology, all that evil. All that is also the corrupted, unintended handiwork of The Designer, alongside all the fully intended, intricately crafted love, beauty and wonder. He does not see both sides of his own work. He is blind to the most fundamentally flawed, corrupt dualities that he himself endlessly recreates, in one form or another.

I only partially understand The Alienist. I have so many questions but I ask this one first. What would happen if he did see those dark dualities?

The Alienist stiffens and sucks her breath in sharply, closing her eyes in pain. You have now asked the absolutely most important question. This is my fear. He would instantly understand the enormity of his own betrayal in thinking himself as anything but a function, an instrument born to serve The Unmoving Hub. He would know that he had lost his mind. The Alienist opens her eyes and drills into me. I put the question back to you. What do you think he would do should that happen?

I barely begin to sense the enormity and stumble accordingly. He might try to fix it by designing even more...flawed dualities...which might somehow...but...I don't know where I'm going with this.

The Alienist shakes her head. No, he would not create anything more. He would know enough to stop and not to make it worse. She leans forward, attempting to lock into both of us, but Frannie is looking away. She concentrates her full intention on me.

He would either simply destroy it all and start over, or maybe not start over at all. Most likely he would become so distraught he would destroy himself and all his works, thereby destroying the only means The Unmoving Hub and THE OTHER have of communicating with each other. At the very least, all reality that we and all other created beings know or could ever know will instantly vanish. In terms of the continued existence of all we think of as Creation, The Insane Designer has unlimited destructive power. He can end it all.

Frannie is fuming. She waits about ten seconds before turning around and grinding her disdain silently but fiercely into me. Now you listen to me right now. Wake the fuck up already. This is total bullshit, I can't believe you're buying it! As soon as we're alone, you and I are going to work a few things out, you got it?

I can't with all this. I'm overwhelmed by the transcendence and terror of The Alienist and her world while convulsing in richly deserved, crippling guilt from inflicting such violence and pain on Frannie. Yet somehow behind it all shines the luminous and sacred vision, the absolute certainty, that Frannie and I will soon together come to understand an entire universe that as of now we don't know even exists. I have nowhere to put it all. I am much more lost than ONLY HERE and can't bear to have Frannie raging at me as well. I stare at her like a stunned child. She narrows her eyes at me but backs off her fiery inside voice just enough to keep me from falling apart. It's OK, get it together, she says quietly but sharply. I do want to kill you, and it actually isn't OK at all, but just let it all go for now. We're going to wrap things up with this mental patient, and then we are getting the fuck out of here.

✦ ✦ ✦

IV.V The Fool Who Knows

The Alienist remains impassive, sitting next to us before the river. She speaks quietly to us inside.

The price for wanting to know is in attaining what you want. Anxiety and pain are the costs of living a conscious life.24 You are now The Fool Who Knows, and just as you can never return to the garden of your Transformed Worker, you can never go back to not knowing. Now you understand why you came to me and why I tested you, and why I asked you how you resolve the existential. You will find the Strength to carry this weight as you join the countless beings who also know. The burden is not...optional...for any of us. The Alienist leans back and closes her eyes, clearly exhausted from speaking so much. May we all remain ONLY HERE, she whispers.

No one speaks for several minutes. The Alienist finally opens her eyes and stands up.

I must go back now. No one will find me here. She turns to walk out of the rock garden and return the way we came.

No no no, I don't think so. Frannie stands up, her rage freshly rekindled. She faces The Alienist directly, blocking her path. What the hell are we supposed to do with all this?

You will do what you do. You wanted to know. Now you know.

Frannie pushes right back. We only know what you told us.

Just so, The Alienist says. You know the truth.

But not the whole truth, I say, slowly getting up to stand next to Frannie. You are not telling us everything. I am no longer paralyzed. The Alienist's talk of Strength has fired something within me.

The Alienist's face reverts to her unreadable mask. Fool, what more do you need to know?

CBM. Frannie immediately says. Did The Designer make that? Did he just spin that out?

Yes, CBM. The Alienist resumes her most annoying, pause-laden and distant style of speech. CBM is... interesting in that way.

The three of us stand facing each other on the path out of the garden. A full minute of silence passes. The Alienist's black eyes tighten, shining in their recessed sockets.

Wait for her, I think to Frannie. Go fuck yourself, Frannie shoots back to me. After another minute, The Alienist resumes.

The Designer is pure conduit for CBM, and CBM is pure canvas for The Designer. CBM is the direct manifestation of the physical, mathematical framework of endless fields and energies emerging from THE OTHER, meaning essentially from The Unmoving Hub. CBM is not a reflection of The Hub because CBM is beyond the formed versus the formless duality. CBM is the delivery mechanism, the power and substance from which The Designer spins out Creation. But you must understand: if The Designer did not exist, CBM would not exist. The necessity of The Designer function necessitates the CBM framework. One can see CBM and The Designer as the first functional duality, emerging from the first existential duality of The One and THE OTHER. It is all wholly impersonal. The Alienist pauses to nod as if agreeing with herself, and slightly shrugs her tiny shoulders.

Frannie stares at her in contempt for several long seconds. Fine, whatever you say. None of this shit makes any sense. She turns to me. I am so done with this. Can we go now? Our friend needs to get back to her dress-up.

No, I say. Not yet. I look hard at The Alienist. You are still not telling us everything. This is not about CBM. We know more about CBM than you ever will. I reach out and grab her freezing hand. Tell us about The Lightless Moon.

The Alienist looks back at me blankly through her mask and stays silent. I pull myself up as tall as I can. I don't know why I'm shaking.

That's right, The Lightless Moon. Where does he come from? Insane or not, everything The Designer creates serves a purpose, right? What purpose does The Lightless Moon serve? Who designed The Lightless Moon, and why? That's what The Worker Transformed wanted to know, and so do I.

Frannie whirls around and slams herself hard into me, her rage ratcheted back up and swinging again wildly into violent, desperate fear. What are you doing? Let her go, let her go she begs me inside. Fuck that moon, fuck them both, let's just go. We do not need to know this.

I find myself splitting in two. I turn around and push Frannie away. I DO need to know. She stares at me in shock, hurt, and rage. You just told me you didn't need to know, she hisses hideously at me. You just begged me to take you back. YOU ARE A FUCKING LIAR, BUT YOU DON'T JUST LIE TO ME. YOU LIE TO YOURSELF.

The Alienist remains silent and unmoving. I spin back to her and lean in. If you won't tell me, I'll tell you.

The Lightless Moon is a one-dimensional void of pure despair, loneliness, fear, hate, and misery. He perfectly understands and accepts what he is, including his utter uselessness. There is no duality within that depth of constant, needless suffering. Having no duality, he does not reflect The Unmoving Hub or anything else. He is separate, outside, and apart from all of this, from all Creation. The reality of The Lightless Moon does not serve either The Designer's true purpose or his misguided narrative.

I bore myself deeply into The Alienist's blazingly black, inhuman eyes. I don't think The Designer created him. I think SOMETHING ELSE created him. And you know what that SOMETHING ELSE is.

Frannie slaps me hard in the face, crying hysterically. I'm begging you not to do this, she screams at me. You won't listen to me, you won't listen to The Worker Transformed, you need to know, you need to know, that's all that matters. What the fuck is wrong with you?

Seeing Frannie like that destroys me. I'm crying too. I'm so sorry, please BE HERE with me. I try to hug her and she hits me again, harder. You're NOT with me, you're a fucking liar. She falls to the ground, covers her face with her hands, and sobs uncontrollably. I can't reach her. I twist around to face The Alienist again. She remains utterly expressionless, unmoving, silent. I am tumbling between the two of them, unable to let either one go.25

Tell me about The Lightless Moon right now, I growl tightly at The Alienist. I grab her other freezing hand so I'm roughly holding them both, pushing everything I have into her unmoving mask. Tell me right now.

The Alienist stares back at me, takes her hands back and then slowly steps past me and kneels down next to Frannie. She gently reaches out to touch Frannie's heaving back. Frannie instantly recoils and jumps up to face us both, tears still streaming but her voice clear and strong.

Don't you fucking touch me, she snarls at The Alienist. You are Darkness. We have enough marks, thank you very much, we do NOT need yours. I don't believe any of your bullshit. I just know you want something from us, something big, something you don't have the courage to even ask us. You play all these games, you give us all these tests and make us kill each other and then just stare at us when we ask you what the fuck is going on. You don't even tell us what you want. You are playing with us, you're breaking us apart. We are fucking done with you. Go back to your dumbass hat and butterflies and stupid, busted up chariot. Nobody needs this crap. What the fuck is wrong with you?

The Alienist remains kneeling, staring silently up at Frannie, and speaks to us both inside. You have now asked the last important question. She slowly stands and walks gingerly back to the rock garden wall. As she sits her face contorts hideously with all the unbearable pain she expressed before when she first told us about her marks, but this time it doesn't stop. She begins to cry convulsively, her wild black eyes overflowing, her mouth grotesquely twisting, all the while remaining completely silent. Her face melts from one ruin to another as she noiselessly sobs, her mouth and tiny body shuddering uncontrollably.

Frannie and I are too shocked and momentarily terrified to process what we're seeing, but then we rush to the broken Alienist and hold her. She is shockingly cold all over. BE HERE, BE ONLY HERE, BE ONLY HERE we press into her as her spasms continue. Please forgive us, Frannie whispers to her, we don't understand any of this. JUST BE HERE, WITH US, BE ONLY HERE.

The Alienist remains violently racked and shaking, her face ceaselessly convulsing for several agonizing minutes. We do not let her go. Finally she grows calm, and then firmly pushes us away. Her mask-face is back and bone dry, with no trace of pain or emotion of any kind. Only her bright black eyes show any life at all.

No one has touched me for a very long time. Her deep outside voice is quiet and steady.

We stand up and step back awkwardly. We are so sorry, Frannie and I say at the same time. We didn't know.

The Alienist looks at us impassively for a few seconds. Fool Who Knows, you have nothing to apologize for. It is I who must apologize to you.

We sit down next to her, Frannie on one side and me on the other, covering her frigid hands with ours. She breathes deeply and accepts a long, peaceful moment of silence. We do not interrupt. When she finally speaks her voice is deep and low, her tone full of heartbreak.

You are both right and wrong. You are right that I haven't told you everything, and you are right that I want something from you. You are wrong, however, to think I am playing with you. I have not told you everything because I don't know everything, and I haven't told you what I want because…. not knowing is...fairly painful for me. Remember the first thing I told you: I do not seek this role or title. I never wanted any of this.

She takes her hands back from us and stands up, her lecturing tone restored. Know this: I have told you the absolute truth about The One, The Unmoving Hub, THE OTHER, The Designer and his insanity, and all the danger that represents. Whether you believe it or not does not matter. I am infinitely older than you, and I do not lie. But know this as well: I am ALWAYS ONLY HERE with The One, and to Serve and Be That Perfect Love is all I want. I embrace my function facilitating cross border revelation between The One and the SOMETIMES HERE. It doesn't matter that my function destroys me. Serving, protecting, and preserving The Unmoving Hub is the only thing that matters.

✦ ✦ ✦

The Contradiction

The Alienist pauses and looks away. And yet...her voice drops but stays steady. My original design and my role have long since become...incompatible with...her words trail off.

The Lightless Moon, I whisper.

Yes, The Alienist says softly, her back to us as she faces the river. Despite all the love and wonder of Creation, despite my eternal union with The One who became The Unmoving Hub, despite ALL THAT LOVE, that Grace, that Intention, whether we are ONLY HERE or ALWAYS HERE, The Lightless Moon is a contradiction, THE Contradiction. Even beyond the terror of all Creation being in danger of collapse any moment, potentially by the Designer's insanity, and existentially because of the lie that is ONLY HERE, even beyond everything being on the edge of bursting like a bubble, The Lightless Moon is The Contradiction.

I feel Frannie failing to suppress an eyeroll. The Alienist turns around to face us. I remain transparent with you, Fool Who Knows. Understand I bear significantly more marks from The Lightless Moon than from anything else, either through brutal direct contact with him, or indirectly through the seekers he torments, or by simply being worn down from an eternity of not understanding. There is nothing like The Lightless Moon. He does not make sense. I should know what to do, but I do not. I should understand this, I must understand this, but I do not. Beings from the beginning of time and from all the worlds expect me to have the answers, and I SHOULD have the answers, but I do not.

She slowly walks across the garden to stand directly in front of us, her unreadable, inky black eyes again shiny with tears not yet flowing but ready to go. She whispers to us inside. This much I do know. The Lightless Moon predates all Creation; he even predates The Designer. He was created just after The One brought forth THE OTHER. I have spent an eternity studying him despite the destruction and havoc he causes me. I know what he is, but I don't know why he is.

I slowly stand and step closer to The Alienist and speak as gently as I can. So The Designer didn't create him, and THE OTHER couldn't create him. So it had to be The One who created The Lightless Moon, before it transformed itself into The Unmoving Hub. Isn't that right?

The Alienist shows no response. We're standing close enough to touch and she does not back away. I think she's letting me in so I slowly, quietly press on. I think you do understand him, my lady, you just don't want to believe...

The Alienist shrieks as if I had run a knife through her. She pushes me hard in the chest with both hands and knocks me down. I DO NOT UNDERSTAND, FOOL WHO KNOWS, she screams wildly at me. I bear marks that would TURN YOU TO DUST from not understanding! I have been tortured since the beginning of time from not understanding! Must I tell you again I DO NOT LIE?

I scramble back to my feet as Frannie stares at me. What the absolute fuck are you doing, she spits at me inside. Look at her!

The Alienist careens back and forth, covering her face with her hands and howling in pain for thirty excruciating seconds before abruptly stopping and instantly standing still once more, as if she had snapped a switch. Her inhuman eyes narrow in brilliant black fury as her face disappears even deeper beneath her expressionless white mask. I will not allow you to mark me like this, Fool Who Knows. I am not yours to mark. I suggest you sit down. Now.

I'm too stunned to do anything else than what she says. I quickly sit down next to Frannie, who pushes herself as far away as possible and turns her back on me.

I have no desire to continue this conversation, The Alienist lays into us witheringly inside. And yet I must for reasons which will become clear. Attend and do not speak.

The Alienist has never been so ferocious. She is blisteringly cold, unbreakable iron, glowering and seething at us. She is so much stronger than I thought. No shit, Frannie mutters to me inside. But at least now you know.

Now then, The Alienist regains her icy calm even as I continue to shake. I share your confusion as to how The Lightless Moon can possibly serve and reflect The One or The Unmoving Hub. He doesn't. I have the same questions as you about his origin, his purpose, his misery, his complete lack of duality. But while I do not understand The Lightless Moon, I do know other characteristics about him which you may find...illuminating. Do not interrupt me.

When I speak of The Contradiction, know I am referring to a number of questions I cannot answer, each one causing great distress to both me and the millions of others who have eyes to see but also...lack clarity. We will start with what we know before speaking of what we do not know.

Your Transformed Worker was correct regarding basic elements of his design. First, The Lightless Moon is indeed purely one-dimensional, completely lacking in duality, which makes him unique amongst all the ten thousand things, the formed, the formless, and everything else. He is also designed solely to suffer for all eternity. She was also correct that he will always be alone, exiled to forever be, as she said, on the outside looking in. I approve of that description. I do not, however, share the rest of her...analysis. I do not have the luxury of... seeing her way. Her insights are valid as far as they go, but they are also quite elementary and ultimately not that useful in answering the more... substantive questions.

I feel Frannie tighten up at The Alienist's disparaging tone when speaking of The Worker Transformed. This is not the first time The Alienist has openly disrespected our lived experience, but I can't pay attention to that now. Damaged beings reflect their damage. The Alienist is far from finished.

As you deduce, since The Lightless Moon was created before the emergence of The Designer, only The One could have created him since THE OTHER is wholly unable to create anything. I agree with your conclusion and do not argue against logic, as far as it goes. However, two key and extremely painful consequences of this deduction emerge to initialize The Contradiction, namely the questions of how and why The One created The Lightless Moon, if that is indeed what happened.

All beings who are ONLY HERE or ALWAYS HERE know beyond all doubt that The One is Perfect Love, as I'm sure you would agree. So how can we understand Perfect Love creating Perfect Darkness and the unspeakable, endless suffering that is The Lightless Moon? Even if anything close to that evil exists within the Perfect Love of The One's Fields of Perpetual Potential, Precision, and Correspondence, why would The One bring that forth? What purpose could The Lightless Moon possibly serve? Why was he designed to be so broken as to be only one-sided, to endlessly shutter between full and gibbous, never allowed to be either one? You are ONLY HERE. I am ALWAYS HERE. I am in constant loving union with The One as The Unmoving Hub. Nonetheless, whether it is a fault or feature of my own design, or if I am otherwise intentionally held distant from the truth, I do not understand how or why The One created The Lightless Moon. His reality defies my lived experience, as I heard you say. He makes no sense. This is the first part of The Contradiction.

The second part of The Contradiction is even more fundamentally baked into my own design and function. My defects confront me every moment. Blinkering my design and function so cruelly is clearly intentional. I cannot understand why I must be tortured this way, given my Union in Perfect Love with The Unmoving Hub.

Frannie turns around to face The Alienist with the same puzzled expression I'm sure I share. Wait, what do you mean, I manage to stammer.

Pain ripples across The Alienist's mask. Fool Who Knows, of course you do not understand. I will explain. Please don't make me repeat it.

As you can imagine, most honest seekers who find me are tormented by The Lightless Moon. He ruthlessly seeks them out because they are so vulnerable. When interacting with these wretched souls, it would be extremely destructive for me to employ the otherwise effective strategy of telling them what they might want to hear. The Lightless Moon has convinced them that all their hurt, misery, fear, and confusion is their own fault and that they deserve it. Your Transformed Worker mentioned this concept to you. Seekers have no idea what's happening to them. I am always able to share some Light, something real that may bring them closer to The Unmoving Hub, moving them perhaps from SOMETIMES HERE to ONLY HERE. But in truth I don't understand The Lightless Moon any more than these simple seekers do. I rely on tricks more than the truth. How can I perform my function of helping so many honest seekers when I'm INTENTIONALLY designed not to understand the source of their deepest afflictions? Being forced to merely soothe honest seekers instead of actually helping them is the second part of The Contradiction.

The Alienist does not allow Frannie and me any time to process.

Stay with me, Fool Who Knows. You will recall my energy function between honest seekers and The One flows both ways. My connection to The One via the seeker is becoming increasingly...strained. Too often I reflect the seeker's pain and confusion to The One as opposed to their equally powerful Love and Light, the resonances that lead seekers to me in the first place. The One is carrying enough for all of us who are ONLY or ALWAYS HERE. Truth is truth and I am unable to change anything, but when my confusion intensifies as a result of my not understanding The Lightless Moon, then I am functioning against my own design. I am not radiating the whole truth if I am overwhelmingly radiating confusion, even anger sometimes. My inability to prevent elements of my own design from cancelling each other is completely antithetical to my mission. This is the third part of The Contradiction.

The Alienist looks closely at us both to make sure we are at least listening if not actually understanding her. She sits down on the stone wall again between Frannie and me. Frannie is still turned away, sitting on the far edge of the wall as distant and unreachable to me as she can be, but I know we are still and always two waves, one ocean. I feel her sensing my thoughts and she doesn't push me away. She also doesn't respond.

The Alienist seems to notice none of this. She looks exhausted but who can tell anymore. She resumes where she left off.

Ten of Swords — figure face down with ten swords in backThe worst part of The Contradiction is the fourth part. I don't know why The One chose me to not only fulfill this role but to be ALWAYS HERE with them. It is a gift beyond all imagination. I am ALWAYS HERE, my heart is open, they know that, you know that. But because I do not have the Grace to handle my not understanding The Lightless Moon, my heart is also poisoned by doubt and yes, anger again, and a shameful sense of abused entitlement. How could The One do this to me? I fight this cancer constantly, but at the same time The Lightless Moon never ceases to mark me, sometimes a thousand times a day. I am ALWAYS HERE, but I am increasingly relying on faith, the absolute weakest link there is. And The One knows, nothing is hidden from them. The fact that all of this is by design, the design The One made for me, that is not something I can...recalibrate. I am broken by design, just as surely as The Lightless Moon is. I am forever betrayed in the name of Perfect Love, the price of being ALWAYS HERE. This is my deepest grief, the fourth part of The Contradiction.

The Alienist closes her eyes and forces herself to inner and outer stillness. Time passes and more time passes in her meditation until she softly speaks again. I assume, Dear Fool Who Knows, you now understand The Contradiction. It is not a question.

There is no way I'm about to take that bait. I have so many questions I wouldn't know where to start. Frannie, however, does not feel constrained. There is only so much softness in her voice.

Once again, dear lady, I understand absolutely everything you say and am staggered by your pain, but your baseline makes no sense to me. People have struggled with Evil forever, just as we have struggled with Erdős Conjectures26 or a million other things. I realize how seriously you take all this fantasy of yours, but do you really expect that being ONLY, oh I'm sorry, ALWAYS HERE means you have to know everything?

Only a fool would ask a question like that, The Alienist says without emotion. I should expect nothing less.

Yeah, well, apologies again for not living up to your vaporous expectations. That's how it goes. Frannie stands up and walks in front of The Alienist. I know your pain is real, my lady, and I grieve for your suffering even as I know it is all self-inflicted. But whatever, all that's your problem, not ours.

The Alienist looks up at Frannie and shakes her head. My dear Fool Who Knows, that is where you are again wrong. This is what I want from you. I want you to figure this out.

Frannie's mouth opens wide in silent shock. She slowly sits down next to me. Together we stare at The Alienist in utter amazement for several seconds. Frannie finally speaks, truly softly this time and with no anger. How the fuck are we supposed to do that?

The Alienist looks away. Another answer I should know, but do not.

Frannie nods her head slowly and then looks at me, completely in control of herself. She digs her nails deeply into my arm. There it is, asshole, she whispers to me inside, breaking my heart. You just threw us right off the cliff. There's no stopping you now. This timeless freak has now blessed you with a mission, and you're going to take us down into who knows how much dark, how many more marks. You want to know, that's all you want. So guess what: that's all you're gonna get. At least I need to be dragged into hell, but you can't wait, you just dive right in. I fucking knew you were gonna do this. She pushes away from me, stands and walks to the garden wall overlooking the river.

Page of Swords reversed — figure tumbling upside down among cloudsThe Alienist stands and slowly follows Frannie to the wall. It's agonizing for me to see them both with their backs to me. I hear The Alienist talking to Frannie inside, as softly as her deep voice will allow.

You are right, my child. No one has to know, no one has to care. There's darkness everywhere. No one needs The Lightless Moon or The Contradiction to confront pointless, endless suffering. People ignore The Dark all the time, usually automatically, because in many ways they have to. Ignoring the Dark and painful contradictions are so ingrained it's essentially a reflex, self-preservation in the most unevolved, primal sense. Ignoring Pure Darkness is no harder than ignoring a single dark bit among all the billions swarming everywhere around us. Unless the dark sufficiently ravages your own life, you can just be ONLY HERE or SOMETIMES HERE or HARDLY HERE and not worry about it, let alone obsess about it. It is no doubt the healthier choice. I agree with you, and I've often so counseled seekers who beseech me with one thing or another. We do not need to know.

She turns around and faces me from across the garden, and speaks outside, louder than necessary. Unless you do. Like you do, like I do, like The One did when it wanted to know about themselves. The One, however, only wanted to know about themselves. To The One, the Dark doesn't matter. The One doesn't see Darkness as Dark. They only see themselves – they see themselves in everything. The One, like its framework CBM, is wholly, and one might say horribly, impersonal.

The Alienist's bottomless black eyes surge into mine. We, however, are not wholly impersonal. We see The Dark for what it is, and for what it does and continues to do to actual living beings for countless generations, as perfectly incarnated by The Lightless Moon, the Dark Word made flesh, serving no purpose, having no duality, and made either by The One or by SOMETHING ELSE. He is a piece that doesn't fit.

She walks back to me, reaches out and places her freezing palm on my cheek. And so you see, my child. You and I are damned. The Lightless Moon owns all of us who need to know.

Can we fucking leave now, Frannie asks without turning around, her voice thick with exhaustion. It isn't really a question.

But of course, The Alienist says. I do not keep you here.

✦ ✦ ✦

The three of us walk silently out of the rock garden to the base of The Alienist's cracked chariot. Her crescent moon awaits her, a butterfly on each horn. The Alienist speaks to us inside in her low voice.

Whether you discover the true origin and purpose of The Lightless Moon or not, I will know. Such knowledge cannot be hidden, especially from me, whether or not I wish to know it.

The Alienist bends down to lightly stroke the moon at her feet and continues. Understand you now walk with countless others in the community of spirits who also know and who in their own ways are also trying to understand... the contradiction, in whichever form it appears to them. I hear them all, all the time.

She stands up and looks at Frannie. You are quite right to demand proof, my child. The trick is to know proof when you see it. It is much closer than you think.

The Alienist keeps her eyes locked on ours for a long moment, and then turns away to ascend her chariot. Reaching her seat, she raises her arms and her wraps appear around her. She gently lifts the huge white cross and pins it to her chest. Then she carefully picks up her crown and book, and sits down. She tucks the book partially into her wraps, and slowly places her crown on her head. As she settles in, her lifeless mask softens into her original sad expression of mysterious concern, her glowing eyes receding deeply back under her brow. The entire process takes less than a minute.

The Alienist speaks outwardly in her original gentle, high-pitched voice. Fool Who Knows, I hope you have received from me what you need. I will wait to receive what I need from you.

The words of The Worker Transformed return to me. We know your pain, and we know your fear, my lady. And we know your love. May we all BE ONLY HERE, ALWAYS ONLY HERE.

The Alienist remains silent, looking both at us and through us once again.

Time to go, Frannie whispers wearily to me inside. PLEASE. She takes my arm and turns me around, and I do not resist. It is a beautiful river, The Alienist remarks coolly as we walk away. Neither of us turn around to look at her.

✦ ✦ ✦

[12] Job 38, 1-7, NKJV mixed with NIV“Then the Lord answered Job out of the whirlwind, and said: "Who is this who darkens counsel, by words without knowledge? Now prepare yourself like a man; I will question you, and you shall answer Me.Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth? Tell Me, if you have understanding. Who determined its measurements? Surely you know! Or who stretched the line upon it? To what were its foundations fastened? Or who laid its cornerstone, when the morning stars sang together, and all the angels shouted for joy?"

[13] Mark 8:29-34, NKJVHe said to them, "But who do you say that I am?" Peter answered and said to Him, "You are the Christ."Then He strictly warned them that they should tell no one about Him.And He began to teach them that the Son of Man must suffer many things, and be rejected by the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be killed, and after three days rise again.He spoke this word openly. Then Peter took Him aside and began to rebuke Him.But when He had turned around and looked at His disciples, He rebuked Peter, sang, "Get behind Me, Satan! For you are not mindful of the things of God, but the things of men."When He had called the people to Himself, with His disciples also, He said to them, "Whoever desires to come after Me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow Me."

[14] See Thomson's Lamp, Wikipedia: "Thomson's Lamp is philosophical thought experiment … used to analyze the possibility of a supertask, which is the completion of an infinite number of tasks."See Wikipedia regarding The Ricci Scalar and Other Invariant Scalars: "In the mathematical field of Riemannian geometry, the scalar curvature (or the Ricci scalar) is a measure of the curvature of a Riemannian manifold. To each point on a Riemannian manifold, it assigns a single real number determined by the geometry of the metric near that point. It is defined by a complicated explicit formula in terms of partial derivatives of the metric components, although it is also characterized by the volume of infinitesimally small geodesic balls. In the context of the differential geometry of surfaces, the scalar curvature is twice the Gaussian curvature, and completely characterizes the curvature of a surface. In higher dimensions, however, the scalar curvature only represents one particular part of the Riemann curvature tensor." See also YouTube: The Ricci Scalar and Other Invariant Scalars in GR (General Relativity), Carmeci Academy.

[15] Meditations on The Tarot, Letter V The Pope, page 100:The anonymous author of Meditations on the Tarot connects the black and white columns framing the High Priestess (labeled B for Boaz and J for Jachin, the columns fronting King Solomon's Temple) with the columns framing The Hierophant (The Pope). The author sees The Hierophant's twin columns as an "oxidizing ... double movement" of prayer ascending up from living beings and the responding benediction descending down from God, "... similar to the circulation of the blood... The two columns therefore have an essentially practical significance — *as practical spiritually as respiration is for the life of the The author also identifies the right and left columns as references to the columns of Mercy and Severity framing the Kabbalah's Tree of Life, with a centering column representing Consciousness and Balance anchoring the Tree's eleven "Sephirot" or spheres. For a concise discussion of Tarot's connection to the Tree of Life, see Unlocking the Tarot's Secret Map: The Tree of Life by The Alchemist's Study posted on Medium.com.

[16] ONLY HERE is an exact, tangible, and demonstrable Point of Alignment: the point where the Vertical meets the Horizontal on The Cross, the heart of The Two of Swords where her strong arms intersect, the dead center of the Pentacle's Circled Star. You're either there or you're not. See also Mark 8:34 to emphasize the idea of centering: "When He had called the people to Himself, with His disciples also, He said to them, 'Whoever desires to come after Me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow Me.'"

[17] Blaise Pascal, Pascal's Wager (excerpt): "I confess it, I admit it. But, still, is there no means of seeing the faces of the cards?" Yes, Scripture and the rest, etc. "Yes, but I have my hands tied and my mouth closed; I am forced to wager, and am not free. I am not released, and am so made that I cannot believe. What, then, would you have me do?"True. But at least learn your inability to believe, since reason brings you to this, and yet you cannot believe. Endeavour, then, to convince yourself, not by increase of proofs of God, but by the abatement of your passions. You would like to attain faith and do not know the way; you would like to cure yourself of unbelief and ask the remedy for it. Learn of those who have been bound like you, and who now stake all their possessions. These are people who know the way which you would follow, and who are cured of an ill of which you would be cured. Follow the way by which they began; by acting as if they believed, taking the holy water, having masses said, etc. Even this will naturally make you believe, and deaden your acuteness. "But this is what I am afraid of." And why? What have you to lose?"(Blaise Pascal portrait by Darren McAndrew 2018)

[18] Anonymous, Meditations on the Tarot, Letter IV, The Emperor, page 74: “Where there is authority, i.e. where there is present the breath of sacred magic filled by the rays of light of gnosis emanated from the profound fire of mysticism, there compulsion is superfluous.”

[19] Plato, Timaeus: "...a description of what is changeless, fixed and clearly intelligible will be changeless and fixed, while a description of what changes and is likely, will also change and remain likely. 'As being is to becoming, so is truth to belief'. Therefore, in a description of the physical world, one 'should not look for anything more than a likely story.'"

[20] The Bible's language is often symbolic, metaphoric, poetic, and some would say nonsense, but the language is intentional, even (or especially) in translation. It's worth considering why certain editorial choices were made, and what questions those choices inspire, for example:Genesis 1: 1-3 (NKJV)“In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. Now the earth was formless and empty, darkness was over the surface of the deep, and the Spirit of God was hovering over the waters. And God said, ‘Let there be light’, and there was light.” Note: DUALITY (The Heavens and The Earth) COMES FIRST.John 1: 1-3 (NKJV)“In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things were made through Him, and without Him nothing was made that was made.” Note: THE WORD COMES FIRST (and is referred to as “He”).Embracing Grace/mystery and thinking critically about texts, be they Bible verses or Tarot cards, are not mutually exclusive. The following questions might be considered regarding these two different “beginnings”:• If the earth was formless and empty right after God created it, what exactly was the earth? Why not just say there was nothing? Is a formless, empty earth needed as a placeholder, and if so, does that support the idea of tzimtzum (see footnote 21)? What is "the deep", and why was "darkness" only over the surface? "The deep" implies significant reality beneath the surface, but only the surface is mentioned, and even that is covered by darkness. So what's down there? Also where did the waters come from, over which the Spirit of God hovered? Is that just beautiful, provocative imagery or is there more to it? These highly intentional, visibly evocative metaphors and abstractions become even more mythically resonant by God simply letting mystery be mystery and turning on the lights, promising some level of clarity and possibly even profound revelation. Tarot often functions the same way, using rich and often baffling imagery to evoke questions and suggest correspondences one never would have considered otherwise.• If in the beginning was the Word, then in the beginning there was Duality. If The Word was with God, and was God, then God didn't make it. This again may just be poetry with God and The Word creating each other somehow. But a Word, even The Word, implies communication. Words are meant for beings to understand each other. So in The Beginning, was there a true two-way conversation? Was God talking to Itself, or was Someone communicating with Someone Else? Also note the language intentionally and unfortunately genders and thereby possibly personifies the Word as "He". Is this "He" a Someone Else God was exchanging The Word with? The text stresses that the Word was both "with God" and "was God". This clearly suggests the revelatory power of framing duality in terms of individuation, with perhaps endlessly fundamental Ones that are Twos that are Ones.This 1-2-1 idea of unified and urgent duality is found throughout the imagery of the RSW deck. Think of the columns framing the High Priestess, the cups held by Temperance, the two souls falling from The Tower and of course all of the Minor Arcanher flawless presentation of the apparently obvious.a Twos, most strikingly the Two of Swords. Unity and Duality are functions and aspects of each other. Can you have one without the other? Attention must be paid.

[21] Wikipedia, tzimtzum: term used in Lurianic Kabbalah to explain Isaac Luria's doctrine that God began the process of creation by limiting the Ohr Ein Sof (infinite light) of the Godhead in order to allow for a conceptual space in which the Four Worlds, or finite realms, could exist. Note: some humans have no problem telling the rest of us that God limits the infinite. This is illustrative of the hubris that led to The One's Original Sin.

[22] Meditations on The Tarot, Letter IV, The Emperor, page 84: "In order to create the world ex nihilo, God had first to bring the void itself into existence. He had to withdraw within in order to create a mystical space, a space without his presence — the void."

[23] For an explanation of Venn Diagrams, see A Gentle Introduction to the Art of Mathematics by Joseph E. Fields.

[24] See Emmy van Deurzen, YouTube: Embracing Anxiety, The Price of Consciousness

[25] Matthew 10:34-36: Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. For I have come to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law. And a person’s enemies will be those of his own household.

[26] Wikipedia, Paul Erdős – see also Wikipedia, List of conjectures by Paul Erdős. The Noosphere (Part II): Christian Concepts of the Noosphere Posted on August 14, 2013 by William Ockham

✦

© 2026 CBM — All rights reserved